Ireland IRELAND 2024 - Bambie Thug - Doomsday Blue

[ESC United Mod Team]

 

[njdevils94]

 

[MopManMoss]

 

[Juliette]

I know people who love this kind of music, but ugh. I'd rather have some random boyband than this. Let's hope the studio version is better!

 

[Shaney1995]

I'm sure she will! The Late Late Show has never been a framework for Irish entries' staging.

I'm irish and usually hate our acts. I liked Brooke as she was hilarious and had a great presence. But I have high hopes for this. A great song. Very different and experimental music like this has dedicated fans.

Bambie is a great performer. You can look her up online. She also has a fairly solid live performing voice. Something the late late doesn't show. Everyone sounded bad on the late late show. Its due to the horrible old studio and the crap sound system.

Brooke was a 3/10 on vocals on the late late show. But a solid 6.5 or 7 on the eurovision stage vocally.

Bambie was a 5 I'd say on the late late show. So she could 100% reach 8 or 9.

I'm confident we can qualify this year with smart staging and bambie given control as she is a very talented artist and visual artist.

I would not be surprised if this is Irelands best result since Jedward with Lipstick. If she nails the staging the world is her oyster. Again I'm not being biased, usually I detest what we send. Like the Timid Adults sent last year (wild youth my as*)

She is divisive both here and abroad. Some calling her satanic. Others saying she's too weird or the song is too much. But others saying she's a genius or the song is unique and fun, some saying she's like Billie Eilish with a metal element and a twang of Gaga.

Reminds me of Lordi. They were loathed by half the public as weird and creepy, too odd and the song too much. Also labeled satanic by the nutter religious folk.

But you just need a dedicated genre following to do well.

 

[Shaney1995]

I know people who love this kind of music, but ugh. I'd rather have some random boyband than this. Let's hope the studio version is better!

This could do well. Another boyband would be bottom of the semi table like last year. Boybands are so 00s or early 2010s. Unless they are unique which they rarely are. The boyband era will return but not for at least another half decade I'd say. It's been dead since 2016/2017.

 

[Juliette]

This could do well. Another boyband would be bottom of the semi table like last year. Boybands are so 00s or early 2010s. Unless they are unique which they rarely are. The boyband era will return but not for at least another half decade I'd say. It's been dead since 2016/2017.

Let's hope for the best, then! I really hope the Eurovision version of this song won't be as crazy, honestly But who knows, maybe that's what the public needs right now.

 

[Shaney1995]

Let's hope for the best, then! I really hope the Eurovision version of this song won't be as crazy, honestly But who knows, maybe that's what the public needs right now.

I think it will be. But the issue is crazy on the late late doesn't work well as its intended for a solo act at a standing microphone haha. It could work in a massive high budget arena

 

[Shaney1995]

I think it's also the cause of his defeat. Singing "Go Tobann" in teen style was the wrong choice. Potentially "Go Tobann" had all the potential to do better than "Doomsday Blue".

Go Tobann was the safer of the two experimental songs. I agree her teen J pop style voice was her big mistake. But i am starting feel Bambie being even more of a risk will pay off.

 

[Irish Cameltoe]

My current best troll entry list is
1. Silvia Night 2. Dustin 3. This.

 

[mauve]

And Ireland climbing in the odds to the 13th place! (I know it's only January and we shouldn't make too much of this, nevertheless it looks wonderful!)

 

[toinou03]

There is possibility to do something of that but as it is, it is a mess. Both parts don't blend and the singing is really bad.
The whole ouija concept is supposed to look very unexpected, horrifying and shocking (a bit like Hatari when it came out) but beyond the photograph, it's quickly very Halloween party... Well, it's a very Instagram entry but it needs some work around it !

 

[SpiritofKeiino]

With the right staging I could see this on the left hand side of the scoreboard.

 

[ag89]

Ireland this year reminds me of everything surrounding Croatia last year... After so many safe years (that took Croatia nowhere) Croatia sent a shocking entry that did well. I am not quite sure about the outcome for Ireland this year since many voters got used to seeing some "shocking" or unusual performances.
However, this allows Ireland to create a proper stage show. It's hard to say how this will finish.

 

[HarryUK]

The reaction we have all been waiting for!

 

[Shaney1995]

I

My current best troll entry list is
1. Silvia Night 2. Dustin 3. This.

It's not a troll song. Listen to it on Spotify. The late late show with its 60 year old studio and awful sound mixing made it awful. She'd a good vocalist usually.

If this is a troll song so was Lordi and Kaarija

 

[Marcos C]

Ireland this year reminds me of everything surrounding Croatia last year... After so many safe years (that took Croatia nowhere) Croatia sent a shocking entry that did well. I am not quite sure about the outcome for Ireland this year since many voters got used to seeing some "shocking" or unusual performances.
However, this allows Ireland to create a proper stage show. It's hard to say how this will finish.

Yes, but what will be shocking to the general public is where the unusual performance is from.

 

[Cathan]

My current best troll entry list is
1. Silvia Night 2. Dustin 3. This.

Ireland this year reminds me of everything surrounding Croatia last year... After so many safe years (that took Croatia nowhere) Croatia sent a shocking entry that did well. I am not quite sure about the outcome for Ireland this year since many voters got used to seeing some "shocking" or unusual performances.
However, this allows Ireland to create a proper stage show. It's hard to say how this will finish.

I genuinely wonder have half the people criticising this entry have even properly listened to it once or even if they have more than once? Its not even remotely comparable to any of these entries

 

[HarryUK]

I don't think we can properly criticise Bambie Thug's performance until we get a live rendition that isn't butchered by RTÉ's dreadful mixing & lighting

Remember there's no jury vote in the semi finals anymore as well

 

[MopManMoss]

1st half but least I can vote for us with my British sim lol

 

[mauve]

Happy to know that I can vote for Ireland this year!