Creating new contests on the forum
- Thread starter Trece
- Start date
- Watchers 13
SpZ
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
I can't really explain it you if you can not grasp the fact that there will not be either Argentine or Brazilian jury. However you can be in the Spanish language jury for 3 editions and send the Argentine song and in the Portuguese language jury and send the Brazilian song. Or even for example be in the English language jury and send the song from Argentina and Brazil if they are both in English.
And instead of having small variety of songs we actually see some people to moving for example to the Hindi jury.
I can't really explain it you if you can not grasp the fact that there will not be either Argentine or Brazilian jury. However you can be in the Spanish language jury for 3 editions and send the Argentine song and in the Portuguese language jury and send the Brazilian song. Or even for example be in the English language jury and send the song from Argentina and Brazil if they are both in English.
And instead of having small variety of songs we actually see some people to moving for example to the Hindi jury.
- Joined
- March 12, 2012
- Posts
- 23,033
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
We started with one finished the other. We must have the right to choose. If you want to send a song in english - send! In Chinese - send! Being a member of the Peruvian jury - be! Send a song in 1950 - send! There are no groups
We started with one finished the other. We must have the right to choose. If you want to send a song in english - send! In Chinese - send! Being a member of the Peruvian jury - be! Send a song in 1950 - send! There are no groups
seb89
Active member
seb89
Active member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
Basicly it's just a copy of FSC with no time restriction and no RoW.
It would be more interesting to create something new, than an enlarged and slightly modified FSC (imo)
Basicly it's just a copy of FSC with no time restriction and no RoW.
It would be more interesting to create something new, than an enlarged and slightly modified FSC (imo)
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
So how about we forget about this new contest, and change the FSC rules for no time restriction
So how about we forget about this new contest, and change the FSC rules for no time restriction
- Joined
- March 12, 2012
- Posts
- 23,033
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
If you want to create a language contest - I have a pass.
I will continue to promote the contest of freedom of choice under the flags of the countries like in Eurovision (the forum about it then I like countries and their culture). I'm sure I'll find support for this contest.
If you want to create a language contest - I have a pass.
I will continue to promote the contest of freedom of choice under the flags of the countries like in Eurovision (the forum about it then I like countries and their culture). I'm sure I'll find support for this contest.
SpZ
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
No Spanish language jury doesnt involve any countries. Lose the concept of countries completely. It can send any song which is in Spanish language whether it is from Spain, Argentina, Poland or the South Pole.
Even though it would probably have a lot of Spanish speaking countries artists as it might be hard to find Polish people sing in Spanish.
The English jury would most likely have like half of songs from non English speaking countries for example.
No Spanish language jury doesnt involve any countries. Lose the concept of countries completely. It can send any song which is in Spanish language whether it is from Spain, Argentina, Poland or the South Pole.
Even though it would probably have a lot of Spanish speaking countries artists as it might be hard to find Polish people sing in Spanish.
The English jury would most likely have like half of songs from non English speaking countries for example.
seb89
Active member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
That would be cool tbh
!
So how about we forget about this new contest, and change the FSC rules for no time restriction
That would be cool tbh
!
- Joined
- March 12, 2012
- Posts
- 23,033
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
FSC is copy of Eurovision so
Yes, new contest sth between FSC and NSC, but at total it will be more interesting without limits (ROW and WL)
FSC is copy of Eurovision so
Yes, new contest sth between FSC and NSC, but at total it will be more interesting without limits (ROW and WL)
r3gg13
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
Time restriction in FSC will never change my friend,. It has always been there (it was even a shorter length before), and it's a part of its core concept.
So how about we forget about this new contest, and change the FSC rules for no time restriction
Time restriction in FSC will never change my friend,
. It has always been there (it was even a shorter length before), and it's a part of its core concept.
seb89
Active member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
Problem is you can't define the 'sth'.
FSC is copy of Eurovision so
Yes, new contest sth between FSC and NSC, but at total it will be more interesting without limits (ROW and WL)
Problem is you can't define the 'sth'
.
- Joined
- March 12, 2012
- Posts
- 23,033
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
Therefore, we decided to create a new contest in which do not have those restrictions that are in the FSC and the NSC.
And now it turns out everyone wants to create an entirely new competition. Why not talk about it before?
Time restriction in FSC will never change my friend,
Therefore, we decided to create a new contest in which do not have those restrictions that are in the FSC and the NSC.
And now it turns out everyone wants to create an entirely new competition. Why not talk about it before?
SpZ
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
By your suggested form of using countries (and with fsc) only 1 song from Estonia is the limit. You can not make a contest which has no limits to make sense. Even NSC has the limit of not using the same artist in the same edition twice which limits entries.
Having more than 1 person per jury itself is a big limit, limiting the songs you personally can send.
By your suggested form of using countries (and with fsc) only 1 song from Estonia is the limit. You can not make a contest which has no limits to make sense. Even NSC has the limit of not using the same artist in the same edition twice which limits entries.
Having more than 1 person per jury itself is a big limit, limiting the songs you personally can send.
r3gg13
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
That is why we are having this discussion Trece, because members want something different, that doesn't have the limits of the other 2 contests. We are still talking and nothing is set in stone yet
That is why we are having this discussion Trece, because members want something different, that doesn't have the limits of the other 2 contests. We are still talking and nothing is set in stone yet
daniels1000
Well-known member
- Joined
- March 12, 2012
- Posts
- 23,033
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
You have to forget FSC and NSC, and stop comparing :?
If you are from Peru, who may participate in FSC only as ROW, or is 30th in WL in NSC and may participate in 1-2 years apart, you would not say
You have to forget FSC and NSC, and stop comparing :?
If you are from Peru, who may participate in FSC only as ROW, or is 30th in WL in NSC and may participate in 1-2 years apart, you would not say