Contact us

СРБИЈА - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stanković - Ovo je Balkan

how do you rate the entry?


  • Total voters
    129

Milos-BC

Well-known member
Joined
September 28, 2009
Posts
12,602
Location
Serbia
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

Just look at how Emina was breathless even at the beginning of the song :lol: (" Ti ti ti i ja doBzivotnBa rob...ja" :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: )

And it's even worse live, believe me.

On the other hand, the studio versions are avilable to listen to, but i can't put them here :p

Milan's live performance is almost identical to the performance in the studio version, which just proves that he can (vocally) "eat Emina for breakfast".
 

voughan4

Member
Joined
March 7, 2010
Posts
17
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

Milan have made reprisals upon Cipella.:D I like it .
 

fokmey

Active member
Joined
March 16, 2010
Posts
116
Location
Istanbul, Turkey
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

Emina should have won! This song is ok but i'm not gonna vote for it (i would vote for Emina)
 

voughan4

Member
Joined
March 7, 2010
Posts
17
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

fokmey said:
Emina should have won! This song is ok but i'm not gonna vote for it (i would vote for Emina)

Cause Mustafa's wife?
 

evilperson

Active member
Joined
October 2, 2009
Posts
3,764
Location
Canada
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

Milos-BC said:
Just look at how Emina was breathless even at the beginning of the song :lol: (" Ti ti ti i ja doBzivotnBa rob...ja" :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: )

And it's even worse live, believe me.

On the other hand, the studio versions are avilable to listen to, but i can't put them here :p

Milan's live performance is almost identical to the performance in the studio version, which just proves that he can (vocally) "eat Emina for breakfast".

Though that may be true, Emina had the best song of the three and it really wasnt that bad when she performed it live. Also vocals would have been the least of her worries, the backings would take over like they did for Turkey and Greece last year.
 

PashonFrut

Active member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
2,268
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

Oliver had the best song, Milan the best performance + voice. Emina was the weakest. She is cute I understand that, but I agree with their decision.
 

Bojan

Well-known member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
5,304
Location
Macedonia / BOKIA
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

evilperson20 said:
Milos-BC said:
Just look at how Emina was breathless even at the beginning of the song :lol: (" Ti ti ti i ja doBzivotnBa rob...ja" :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: )

And it's even worse live, believe me.

On the other hand, the studio versions are avilable to listen to, but i can't put them here :p

Milan's live performance is almost identical to the performance in the studio version, which just proves that he can (vocally) "eat Emina for breakfast".

Though that may be true, Emina had the best song of the three and it really wasnt that bad when she performed it live. Also vocals would have been the least of her worries, the backings would take over like they did for Turkey and Greece last year.
xgood
it's not the best voice contest it's the song contest!
and as many said here Emina HAD the best song!
I personally preferd Oliver songs over Milan's too! Predsednice Halo has a crazy good ryhthm! xdance
 

Borderline

Well-known member
Joined
February 27, 2010
Posts
601
Location
UK
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

I like Emina's song. It's catchy!
 

Milos-BC

Well-known member
Joined
September 28, 2009
Posts
12,602
Location
Serbia
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

"The best song" is also a subjective thing. My favorite was Oliver, but that doesn't mean that it's best song. The audience chose their favorite, and i am satisfied with it, as i would have been with any of the 3, as i said that i like all 3 of them. And they are really not that different that Emina's song can be THAT good, and Milan's THAT bad (according to many comments from the Serbian people here), it's more likely that it's the fact that Grand singer won, and they can't accept that. Emina is much better to look at ( :p ), but it's not a beauty contest either. Vocal performance surely isn't that important, but it is MORE important than beauty.

EDIT: Emina's song would sound much better if there was someone who could actually sing it properely. If she lost her voice in the beginning here, what would've happened in Oslo then? We would get to hear the instrumental only. Emina was vocally much weaker than Milan and Oliver.

EDIT 2 : And as much as i don't like Grand they were much more fair than RTS, who were clearly favorising Emina. All 3 contestants appeared on "Grand Show" on Friday, and they didn't give a single sign of putting Milan ahead of others, while RTS was only talking about Emina.

For the first time the televoting results are fair and square. But as we say "Ko gubi, ima pravo da se ljuti" :D
 

Bojan

Well-known member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
5,304
Location
Macedonia / BOKIA
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

oh she messed up the lyrics if you clearly hear it in the begining, she did not lost her voice for god's sake :roll: she gave pretty solid vocal performance for this type of song until the end.
 

Luka

Active member
Joined
January 10, 2010
Posts
43
Location
MONTENEGRO
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

I completely agree with Bojan...You can clearily hear that she made mistake with word ''dozivotna'' and then she only sad ''rob..'' ...I don`t know why are they still insisting that her voice is not good,when IT IS.
 

Bojan

Well-known member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
5,304
Location
Macedonia / BOKIA
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

Luka said:
I completely agree with Bojan...You can clearily hear that she made mistake with word ''dozivotna'' and then she only sad ''rob..'' ...I don`t know why are they still insisting that her voice is not good,when IT IS.
yeah I dunno the same :? I mean she's not Marija Serifovic (voice wise :p ) but she can sing well.
 

hechicera

Active member
Joined
February 6, 2010
Posts
64
Location
Serbia
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

Well, I guess I've bashed our national selection (:sigh:) enough on my blog (yeah, I am THAT shameless self-promoting blogger :lol: ), but there's something that I would really love to point out once again...

Look, as long as I remember, I've been a fan of Eurovision. Seriously. My earliest memories are somehow related to ESC. And, in spite of what you might think, I have nothing against ethnic elements in song. For crying out loud, one of my favorite ESC song is "Quien maneja mi barca".
But there has to be a limit. I mean come on! Eurovision is supposed to be a pop-festival. As we say in Serbia, a festival of "light notes". None of these 3 songs are even remotely suitable for a contest such as Eurovision. Above it all, all 3 songs were THE SAME. Uptempo, ridiculous, pathetic and... IMHO, idiotic.
One can trivialize ESC as much as he/she wants, but it still is a spectacle with huge audience and press coverage. And not only that we didn't send a suitable pop song (God knows we have good singers and bands), but we sent something that we should be... well, ashamed of. I am sorry to say, if we really want to promote our country the best way we can - this is not the way to do it.
 

Interrail

Active member
Joined
October 11, 2009
Posts
1,648
Location
SRB
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

^ I just red your blog. LOL. I really enjoyed it, event though I don't share 100% your opinion, I agree on many stuff. Anyway, blog was interesting enough to read all those lines...my compliments!:D
I think your blog opens much wider discussion, not only Milan Stankovic.
ME: I don't mind Milan going to Oslo (said it before), and for me all 3 songs were pretty much similar, ppl chose Milan, he'll go, that's it. I'm fine with it.
The part of 'wider problem' might be - RTS and its approach to Eurovision. If songs were wrong (in past and now), it's exclusively RTS fault, noone else. Because RTS decided about Beovizija finalists in past, and when they invited Bregovic this year, they new he doesn't produce pop-eurovision-style songs.
Ofcourse RTS wanted 'ethnic' (if it's ethnic at all) trumpet up tempo, and ofcourse RTS wanted ridiculous lyrics, otherwise RTS would never invite MT and Bregovic.
But we should be aware that broadcaster decide the way the song would be chosen. It's totally up to RTS. They can just say - we send this, no jury, no audience, we choose internally - which is much worse then the system we have now.
RTS is a bit stubborn, old fashioned and they think it's an absolute MUST to show Europe Serbian ethno, every year and every time when they have chance. Sometimes it can be fun, sometimes they're just boring with it (RTS).
I think our songs will never change until RTS open its mind to other music styles. God, I hope these other music styles won't be ordinary usual eurovision songs - I totally hate them, it was good 15 years ago, but now...?? I also think many other ESC countries r very wrong with their choices, many of them haven't been evolved since 1980, which is (IMHO) just as same bad as RTS 'strategy'.
And I also think Eurovision shouldn't be taken too seriously, I mean... it's wrong when countries think they can promote themselves through Eurovision, because they can't. Best promotion for countries r when they're OK in many different fields...sports, culture, economy, bla bla bla...
Well, for instance, I think 'Serbian movie' (Srdjan Spasojevic) is MUCH better promotion then any Eurovision, even if we win hundred times.
So, in conclusion...purpose of Eurovision is not to promote countries, it's just to show some new, fresh, original music (if broadcaster can do it), not to recycle ethno or pop-eurotrash all over again, every year. If countries r not able to come up with anything new, but only old style...then...they should withdraw for some time. This year I would be totally fine if we had only (perhaps) 10 countries in ESC, cause majority is so baaaadd, for my taste.
And one word about Milan - I think best song out of these 3 won (no matter how bad all they r), it will be good for internal use, internal market, not best choice for Eurovision and not worst in Eurovision, but..nevermind:D I'm not a big fan of Emina either - wheres her voice? She hardly can speak, not to mention singing.
 

Hrvatska19

Active member
Joined
December 10, 2009
Posts
385
Location
Perth, Australia
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

I know this is a bit off topic! but i just wanna acknowledge Ksenija Pajcin! I'm sure you all heard that she was murdered by her bf over 'jealousy'! and i know that she was probably no angel but to be taken in that way is just horrible! i quite liked her music..its the type that always put a smile on ur face and made things seem a little less sad,bad,depressing than what they really were! in fact last night before i heard of all this i was thinking that Serbia should send her to ESC next year!...

pocivaj u miru :-(
 

evilperson

Active member
Joined
October 2, 2009
Posts
3,764
Location
Canada
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

^ Yes I read about that yesterday, truly awful. Hopefully her family stays, strong especially her mother. I can't imagine how it must feel to find your child murdered...it really sends shivers down my spine. May she rest in peace.
 

Simon87

Well-known member
Joined
November 15, 2009
Posts
11,407
Location
Simon city
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

:( :( :(
 

hechicera

Active member
Joined
February 6, 2010
Posts
64
Location
Serbia
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

@Interrail

I know this is going to sound a bit weird, but ESC forum is the last place on Earth that I would expect to find someone who appreciates Serbian Film. :) I share your view and I think that it will promote the hell outta Serbia. Of course, in a positive way.
And, of course - RTS (actually, the small group of people who are there year after year) is the only responsible for our entries. As I've said before somewhere on this forum, I really don't understand why does RTS think that we cannot offer nothing but ethno to Europe? I mean, we sent pop song only once - and we won. We have good composers, we have good singers and bands, so what's the hold-up?
 

Iluzionista

Member
Joined
March 16, 2010
Posts
21
Location
Serbia
Re: ?????? - Serbia 2010 - Milan Stankovi? - Ovo je Balkan

Gordon said:
Iluzionista said:
An absolute waste. This song doesn't deserve to go to the finals, and probably won't.
Let's face it, our two last entries sucked big time.

Jelena too? :shock:

No, I mean this year's and last year's. ;)

And one more thing. That Tijanic guy is really getting on my nerves. For someone who claims to have integrity and good taste, he's proven himself to be nothing more than ordinary "seljacina". :lol:
 
Top Bottom