Luxembourg LUXEMBOURG 2024 - Tali - Fighter

[ESC United Mod Team]

 

[lasse braun]

luxembourg is back and how!
they were never away - great show - wonderful moderation and an extra for desiree and my old memories.
but there was also something not so good - first the votemode - crazy to give 3 superfinalists jurypoints and not televote only like in
many other countries = jury & tele all 8 and then tele only in the superfinal.
second: the winner song.
it's an ok song for me but not a great one or near.
my personal winner was this young lovely girl - she was the act with the core of luxembourgs ESC music tradition.

 

[jatojo]

luxembourg is back and how!
they were never away - great show - wonderful moderation and an extra for desiree and my old memories.
but there was also something not so good - first the votemode - crazy to give 3 superfinalists jurypoints and not televote only like in
many other countries = jury & tele all 8 and then tele only in the superfinal.
second: the winner song.
it's an ok song for me but not a great one or near.
my personal winner was this young lovely girl - she was the act with the core of luxembourgs ESC music tradition.

My favourite song before the show - but she was too tense. I could see it in her eyes from the first second of the performance, and it influenced her vocal.

 

[Loindici]

There's something refined and clean about it. It's a rich and lush pop song, don't know how it will fare with the public though.

the amount of antisemetic bs ive seen on twitter over this woman winning is insane im so glad we have this forum its the most civil and level headed eurovision discussion place on the internet by far

Taking into account that Luxembourg Song Contest is produced by Tali Eshkoli... wait, what am I thinking?

Luxembourg: Tali Eshkoli producer of Luxembourg Song Contest - Eurovision News | Music | Fun

Israeli TV producer Tali Eshkoli has taken over the production of the Luxembourg Song Contest, Luxembourg’s national final, in its grand return to the competition 31 years after its last entry! Tali Eshkoli is no stranger to pageant fans. She has been the head of Israel’s Eurovision delegation...

eurovisionfun.com

 

[MopManMoss]

There's something refined and clean about it. It's a rich and lush pop song, don't know how it will fare with the public though.

Taking into account that Luxembourg Song Contest is produced by Tali Eshkoli... wait, what am I thinking?

Luxembourg: Tali Eshkoli producer of Luxembourg Song Contest - Eurovision News | Music | Fun

Israeli TV producer Tali Eshkoli has taken over the production of the Luxembourg Song Contest, Luxembourg’s national final, in its grand return to the competition 31 years after its last entry! Tali Eshkoli is no stranger to pageant fans. She has been the head of Israel’s Eurovision delegation...

eurovisionfun.com

I have made my stance on Israel clear on this forum several times there is zero excuse for people claiming tali won because she is Israeli and the production of the nf was done by Israelis that is getting into flat earther conspiracy territory

 

[CPV4931]

My favorite winning this NF, nice choice :-)

 

[empo21]

from me with a chance to rise. The best performance won imo

It's a shame the staging has to be altered because of the 6 people rule. The 6 dancer choreo looked so good.

 

[NemesisNick]

I watched Luxembourg's national final, Luxembourg Song Contest 2024 live, online from the UK, yesterday evening (Saturday 27 January 2024). I've made a video containing my opinions on all eight finalist songs, in order of performance (based on Luxembourg Song Contest 2024 performances), and my ranking from eighth to first in My Eurovision Scoreboard.

Nemesis Nick Talks Eurovision: Luxembourg Song Contest 2024 Review

 

[Juliette]

I'm secretly obsessed with this kind of music.

 

[Iker]

It's good to have Luxembourg back! I'm yet to listen to Fighter though, lol. But it seems that Tali won't embarrass Luxembourg this judging from what I read so far.

 

[MopManMoss]

I like fighter it vaguely reminds me of the music of Jain

 

[RainyWoods]

Something really strange is happening in NFs so far this year. My favourite has won in each of them (..well, 3rd or so fav in Albania but still). Luxembourg's selection though was extremely mediocre so I can't exactly say I'm excited.

Fighter is decent and the sensible choice. Maybe Luxembourg can enjoy a boost this year from the novelty of their return after so many decades away? The whole thing's energy is quite low-key and I do get some flop vibes from the entry that are hard to explain. I feel they will need to ramp it all up in some way to make the song and performance more memorable. It's a pleasant little bop but not much more.

points

 

[Bobjan FR]

Results of the first round : https://eurovision.rtl.lu/news/a/2163909.html

Basically, in the first round, tali won the jury vote and public vote. So without a superfinal, krick would not have been the "public choice throw in the bin because of the judges"

 

[Decayingbooks]

Luxembourg chances of qualifying are quickly dwidling, not a single french speaking country votes on semi 1

 

[rasmuslights]

Luxembourg chances of qualifying are quickly dwidling, not a single french speaking country votes on semi 1

And no Netherlands as well. :/

 

[0scar]

And no Netherlands as well. :/

Luxembourg didn't lose any possibly friendly points there, are not as close as you'd guess

but yeah Luxembourg is in big trouble
No Israel either

 

[Sabrewulf238]

I feel like the only thing Luxembourg has going for it right now are the "Hey you're back" votes.

Maybe that will still be enough to get them over the line.

Though I guess how much you care about voting that way might depend on if you have any memory of Luxembourg competing in the contest before. (or you're a superfan who loves old Luxembourg entries) For a lot of people I guess Luxembourg will just feel like a new country participating.

 

[HarryUK]

I'm watching the interval back with all the former winners and it's reinforced my desire to have Charlotte Perrelli back for Sweden!!!

 

[ZoboCamel]

I'm putting this in the Malta-bucket of "perfectly functional but entirely forgettable radio pop." I never quite got the praise for it when the studio versions came out, and the live performance (while fine) did nothing more to convince me.

It does at least get a slight leg up over Malta for the native language, the decently moody verses and the less-irritating chorus melody, but that's still only enough to stretch it to , I think.

 

[Gera11]

This is fading incredibly fast, downgraded it to a

 

[Yoozek]

That's a tough one to sing right, while it's not making a grand impression at the same time. Pity, that song written by Elsie Bay was a better choice imho.