Israel ISRAEL 2014 - Mei Finegold - Same Heart
- Thread starter escYOUnited
- Start date
- Watchers 29
Iuris
Active member
I'm not a fan of Patricia Kaas and I don't like such a harsh voices. 0 pts
Maybe, it's the best asset of the candidature, its main attraction.
cassio
Well-known member
on the + side:
Very well written pop/rock song
Strong dark voice.
closest competitor: UK (as of 5.3.14) Israel is better!
on the - side:
Mix langue lyrics
Not a ESC winner type of song (you need costumes like Lordi in 2006)
Israel: 8 pts.
Very well written pop/rock song
Strong dark voice.
closest competitor: UK (as of 5.3.14) Israel is better!
on the - side:
Mix langue lyrics
Not a ESC winner type of song (you need costumes like Lordi in 2006)
Israel: 8 pts.
And how many people have won without a costume?
Besides that's always been their style, they didn't put on the costumes because it would shock the audience (although they did, of course)For me it's just not memorable
I can't remember a single line or the melody and I've already heard it twice.
WinMei
Member
- Joined
- January 10, 2014
- Posts
- 115
For me it's ok. I thought this song will win and it did. I like some parts... don't know how it sounds live. So ..
Be sure she's even better live performances than in studio!
She is going to give show!!!!! xbb
cassio
Well-known member
And how many people have won without a costume?
For me it's just not memorable
Celia I think that you misunderstood what I mean by type of song....... I mean ROCK!!! It is not just a pop song it has elements of rock. Looking at the past winners the closets pop/rock type of music it can think of as a winner is Lordi.
94ayd
Well-known member
Very good choice, but something about it just doesn't scream 1st place to me - points.
points. 
VikingTiger
Well-known member
Not too bad. Not too good. Great voice. Last part of the song is quite good!
My bad then, sorry
although I think Lordi's song sounds nothing like this at all. I would have never made that connection.
theditz83
Veteran
Oh wow, this was a surprise. A lot more "ballsy" than I remember Israel being in a while. Great voice, and awesome key-change! Can see this qualifying quite easily 
8 points for now
8 points for now
ParadiseES
Well-known member
Wait! Wait! Did they choose a song? I didn't expect to see the song already
At least they chose the best one
I can't give 12 points because Mei's voce still irritates me, but since the song is amazing I'll give it 10
No way Israel is out of the final this year
At least they chose the best one
I can't give 12 points because Mei's voce still irritates me, but since the song is amazing I'll give it 10
No way Israel is out of the final this year
cassio
Well-known member
My bad then, sorry
well yes Lordi was a bit more hard rock/rock .... where this song is more pop/rock but I can't find another winner song that I would categorize as Rock
ParadiseES
Well-known member
BTW I hope whoever makes the running order this year will separate and cause these two songs are quite similar (talking about the styles ), they could cancel each other and it would be such a pity. Both deserve to do well!
and cause these two songs are quite similar (talking about the styles ), they could cancel each other and it would be such a pity. Both deserve to do well!
GWTW1939
Active member
The transition from English to Hebrew happens so fast it sounds like she's singing "I touch your d**k" 
1 
3
I
everytime I listen to it. The last minute is absolute HEAVEN... starting with that key change 
1 3I
everytime I listen to it. The last minute is absolute HEAVEN... starting with that key change 
kengaIME
Active member
A-lister
Veteran
- Joined
- December 28, 2009
- Posts
- 32,825
The transition from English to Hebrew happens so fast it sounds like she's singing "I touch your d**k"
Luv it!
Anyways, the best choice has been made Israel...
RainyWoods
Croak-kay
I just listened to the other two songs and all I can say is how disappointed I am now
What they have chosen here is by far the blandest of the three songs. It's literally just going to blend in with the other pop-rock entries of the year, especially Macedonia and Italy, both of which probably have stronger songs. "Be Proud" would have been a pretty neat entry. It sounds like a James Bond number. That would have been something a little different and at least could have stood on it's own.
On a plus note, can I just say I loved the music videos accompanying the songs Real lofi charm to them. It was as if David Lynch was behind the camera.
What they have chosen here is by far the blandest of the three songs. It's literally just going to blend in with the other pop-rock entries of the year, especially Macedonia and Italy, both of which probably have stronger songs. "Be Proud" would have been a pretty neat entry. It sounds like a James Bond number. That would have been something a little different and at least could have stood on it's own.
On a plus note, can I just say I loved the music videos accompanying the songs
Real lofi charm to them. It was as if David Lynch was behind the camera.