IRELAND 2012 - Jedward - Waterline
- Thread starter escYOUnited
- Start date
- Watchers 51
sannerz
Active member
Re: IRELAND 2012
GO ANDREW MANN!
GO ANDREW MANN!
QwaarJet
ESC Moderator
Re: IRELAND 2012
I shall join you in that happy place. I still hold some hope that Jedward will fall, probably by the hands of Donna.
I guess I'm being unreasonably optimistic. But leave me in my "happy place"
I shall join you in that happy place. I still hold some hope that Jedward will fall, probably by the hands of Donna.
Bart
Active member
Re: IRELAND 2012
I think Lipstick was better than Waterline and I see the twins winning again since the other songs are really bad.
I think Lipstick was better than Waterline and I see the twins winning again since the other songs are really bad.
pedrogerman
Active member
- Joined
- December 18, 2010
- Posts
- 41
theditz83
Veteran
Re: IRELAND 2012
I can only compare Jedward's second attempt to taht of Lena last year (since it's the most recent and therefore probably still the most relevant comparison). She won in 2010, and then only just managed to scrape a 10th place finish last year with the final country's vote. Jedward got 8th last year, so I can only expect that they'd struggle to make the top 15 this year (if they even advance from the semi). Gimmicks don't last for long - you need more than some bouncing around and ridiculous hair to have success.
If Ireland wants all of Europe to roll their eyes, put Jedward through.
If Ireland wants Europe to be captivated by a modern and unique composition, put Andrew Mann through (his track has grown on me immensely).
If Ireland wants to live in the past, put Celtic Whispers ft. Maria McCool or Una & David through.
And if Ireland wants to embrace a classic pure-pop anthem, Donna is the only choice.
DONNA or ANDREW for Baku!!
I can only compare Jedward's second attempt to taht of Lena last year (since it's the most recent and therefore probably still the most relevant comparison). She won in 2010, and then only just managed to scrape a 10th place finish last year with the final country's vote. Jedward got 8th last year, so I can only expect that they'd struggle to make the top 15 this year (if they even advance from the semi). Gimmicks don't last for long - you need more than some bouncing around and ridiculous hair to have success.
If Ireland wants all of Europe to roll their eyes, put Jedward through.
If Ireland wants Europe to be captivated by a modern and unique composition, put Andrew Mann through (his track has grown on me immensely).
If Ireland wants to live in the past, put Celtic Whispers ft. Maria McCool or Una & David through.
And if Ireland wants to embrace a classic pure-pop anthem, Donna is the only choice.
DONNA or ANDREW for Baku!!
Re: IRELAND 2012
My thoughts:
Una Gibney & David Shannon - The composition of it quite surprised me and it's quite alright but I can't believe the cheesiness of it, especially the lyrics. Shina a light, language of love? Seriously?
It's like they've tried to throw every love song cliché into it...
Andrew Mann - This song is kinda boring and "Here I Am" is such an overused song title :L
Donna McCaul - Typical pop song but it's one of the better choices on offer here
Maria McCool - Ireland's token Celtic sounding downtempo song This is boring as hell and so old fashioned. Please Ireland don't choose this.
Jedward - I really dislike it when an artist from the previous year comes back but I think it's for the best this time. I'm definitely feeling the Busted vibes other people have suggested and it's different from Lipstick which helps
My ranking:
1. Jedward
2. Una Gibney & David Shannon
3. Donna McCaul
4. Andrew Mann
5. Maria McCool
So yeah...Jedward to Baku please... :/ xD
My thoughts:
Una Gibney & David Shannon - The composition of it quite surprised me and it's quite alright but I can't believe the cheesiness of it, especially the lyrics. Shina a light, language of love? Seriously?
It's like they've tried to throw every love song cliché into it...Andrew Mann - This song is kinda boring and "Here I Am" is such an overused song title :L
Donna McCaul - Typical pop song but it's one of the better choices on offer here
Maria McCool - Ireland's token Celtic sounding downtempo song
This is boring as hell and so old fashioned. Please Ireland don't choose this.Jedward - I really dislike it when an artist from the previous year comes back but I think it's for the best this time. I'm definitely feeling the Busted vibes other people have suggested and it's different from Lipstick which helps
My ranking:
1. Jedward
2. Una Gibney & David Shannon
3. Donna McCaul
4. Andrew Mann
5. Maria McCool
So yeah...Jedward to Baku please... :/ xD
MyHeartIsYours
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 22, 2010
- Posts
- 24,545
Re: IRELAND 2012
I think people who are on about the Jedward gimmick too are ignoring the fact that Waterline is actually the best song here too!
I think people who are on about the Jedward gimmick too are ignoring the fact that Waterline is actually the best song here too!
anto475
Well-known member
Re: IRELAND 2012
I'm really worried that Jedward will actually win it, despite the meagreness of their song. I saw about 20 Jedheads out on O'Connell Street there over the weekend in a big group trying to garner support, and it's that mobilised force that will swing it for them. Even though Donna has a better song, her voting clout has diminished severely since 2005. Back then her uncle draped a large banner asking people to vote for herself and her brother over his pub in the middle of their town, but now his pub has closed down and I don't think many people know she's going for it outside of a few circles. So then I think that the majority watching the Late Late, which probably will consist of the elderly here as they tend to be the main audience for it, might vote for Maria McCool or possibly Language of Love, and then the Jedward Army, who are bloody terrifying btw, will vote en masse for Jedward and then we'll be left with a disappointing result in Baku because of a) a weak song and b) the lack of countries that normally vote for us in our Semi.
Oh well.
I'm really worried that Jedward will actually win it, despite the meagreness of their song. I saw about 20 Jedheads out on O'Connell Street there over the weekend in a big group trying to garner support, and it's that mobilised force that will swing it for them. Even though Donna has a better song, her voting clout has diminished severely since 2005. Back then her uncle draped a large banner asking people to vote for herself and her brother over his pub in the middle of their town, but now his pub has closed down and I don't think many people know she's going for it outside of a few circles. So then I think that the majority watching the Late Late, which probably will consist of the elderly here as they tend to be the main audience for it, might vote for Maria McCool or possibly Language of Love, and then the Jedward Army, who are bloody terrifying btw, will vote en masse for Jedward and then we'll be left with a disappointing result in Baku because of a) a weak song and b) the lack of countries that normally vote for us in our Semi.
Oh well.
QwaarJet
ESC Moderator
Re: IRELAND 2012
You opinion does not make it a fact. I personally think it's the weakest song. I'm not denying that they will win this cause of the product that they are but don't throw the word "fact" around when there is no such thing in a subjective world.
You opinion does not make it a fact. I personally think it's the weakest song. I'm not denying that they will win this cause of the product that they are but don't throw the word "fact" around when there is no such thing in a subjective world.
sannerz
Active member
Re: IRELAND 2012
^ Oh, no. If he says it it's fact. The queen says so.
Andrew Mann is by far my favorite, and I hope he can surprise with a win.
^ Oh, no. If he says it it's fact. The queen says so.
Andrew Mann is by far my favorite, and I hope he can surprise with a win.
MyHeartIsYours
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 22, 2010
- Posts
- 24,545
Re: IRELAND 2012
I used fact as a figure of speech. I dont tend to take things people write so literally but you know...
I used fact as a figure of speech. I dont tend to take things people write so literally but you know...
Re: IRELAND 2012
Jedward have the best song here imo, and I find it much better than the annoying "Lipstick" entry, but I think they will get nowhere with that song in case they win, and that can be said for other songs here as well.
I expected stronger entries, but I have to say it is quite a weak NF, unfortunately And also, I see none of these entries doing well in Baku.
Jedward have the best song here imo, and I find it much better than the annoying "Lipstick" entry, but I think they will get nowhere with that song in case they win, and that can be said for other songs here as well.
I expected stronger entries, but I have to say it is quite a weak NF, unfortunately
And also, I see none of these entries doing well in Baku.
bashers
Active member
Re: IRELAND 2012
Where can I see this programme online?
Where can I see this programme online?
Isabella
Active member
Re: IRELAND 2012
My ranking:
1. Mercy
2. Mistaken
3. Here I am
4. Waterline
5. Language of love
Mercy or Mistaken ftw
My ranking:
1. Mercy
2. Mistaken
3. Here I am
4. Waterline
5. Language of love
Mercy or Mistaken ftw
bashers
Active member
Re: IRELAND 2012
I actually think the songs this year for Ireland are very good. Bit of a variety going on. Some of the songs would have won hands down 10-15 years ago its just a shame as to what Europe will like in 2012. I like Mercy by Donna. It's a get up and dance type of song and would be a crowd pleaser. Waterline will get through just because of Jedward's fanbase. I prefer to last year's song but I think it will have Lena's downfall like last year. Language of Love is very very cheesy but has the right message. Here I am would have been good years back but I don't think there is an appeal for this type of song this year. As for Mistaken....mystical, cultural and is actually quite good! For me this song might have appeal that people would appreciate as is going back to their celtic roots. I'd be happy with Mercy, Mistaken or maybe even Jedward's.
I actually think the songs this year for Ireland are very good. Bit of a variety going on. Some of the songs would have won hands down 10-15 years ago its just a shame as to what Europe will like in 2012. I like Mercy by Donna. It's a get up and dance type of song and would be a crowd pleaser. Waterline will get through just because of Jedward's fanbase. I prefer to last year's song but I think it will have Lena's downfall like last year. Language of Love is very very cheesy but has the right message. Here I am would have been good years back but I don't think there is an appeal for this type of song this year. As for Mistaken....mystical, cultural and is actually quite good! For me this song might have appeal that people would appreciate as is going back to their celtic roots. I'd be happy with Mercy, Mistaken or maybe even Jedward's.