It was time for
at the ESC kompakt songchecks 2024.
Wohl selten gab es um die Auswahl des isländischen Beitrags für den Eurovision Song Contest so viel Aufhebens wie in diesem Jahr. Am Ende setzte sich gegen alle Erwartungen die bereits ESC-erprobte…
esc-kompakt.de
The verdict of the bloggers:
Benny - Yeah, Heras seconds ESC attempt is completely fallen out of time and also produced in a very flat way. Too bad, even though I think she´ll pull out the best on stage. Nevertheless a certain pleasant listening effect has set in for me and now I find "Scared of Heights" quite entertaining, in a guilty pleasure way.
Berenike - I like this much more than I should. Even though it´s absolutely not innovative the melody appeals to me and I just have to rock along. Hera is and stays a Disco diva who´s very present as a person and with her voice, and due to the choir the song gets something hymn like.
Douze Points - Classy, timeless, uplifting - all that is "Scared of Heights". Innovative, contemporary, activating to vote - the entry is sadly none of that. Hera is an ESC icon and and a safe bet when it comes to the vocals.The song may suit her as well, but she´s unlikely to achieve a bigger success at the ESC. Nevertheless I enjoy the three minutes, rock along and give
.
Flo - As much affection Hera Björk earns, this entry is simply boring. And she could´ve done so much more with her ESC comeback, because vocally she´s in the forefront of course. But that leaves a title hardly worth of any recogniton and that will have a hard time winning the audience votes in the semifinal.
Manu - Phew, if Hera did herself a favour with this?? "Scared of Heights" struggles somewhere between "Hold My Hand" by Jess Glynne and "Embers" by James Newman for me, but isn´t by far as good produced and is even temporarily sinking a bit in a musical sound mud. I already forget this entry while listening to it, but I´m at least delightet by the choir. But then rather send the original Uschi Blum (stage figure of famous German comedian Hape Kerkeling) to ESC, then the final is possible. This way only
.
Max - This year Iceland is standing out with everything - but not with the actual ESC entry. This will presumably a guaranteed failure in the semifinal. The song isn´t even bad, it´s just not impressive and since you´re relying on the audience vote in the semi not even Heras voice can get some jury votes. Iceland can do that better actually...
Peter - Hera is - despite all the complexity when looking at her "life's work" - an icon in the bubble. First of all, it’s great that she “sticks with it”. This year's contribution to Iceland is decent musical home cooking, easy on the ear, but not really distinct and not for ESC eternity. Good groove, danceable, very well sung, relatable but by no means original message.
(because it’s Hera)
Rick - I understand the criticism that "Scared of Heights" is a bit old-fashioned in some passages. It doesn´t really bother me though, because it looks like this nostalgic feeling is intentional. In combination with the contemporary dance production the song gets elevated, which makes the whole thing harmonious. Nevertheless it´s not the really big hit though and I think Iceland will have a difficult time to reach the final since the song is just too unspectacular.