Creating new contests on the forum
- Thread starter Trece
- Start date
- Watchers 13
daniels1000
Well-known member
SpZ
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
I know people who could potentially do it and both Swahili and Udmurt would be really high in my languages to pick list.
But who will particiapte for Uzbek language?
I know people who could potentially do it and both Swahili and Udmurt would be really high in my languages to pick list.
Hele.
Well-known member
- Joined
- April 3, 2011
- Posts
- 11,370
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
Please do a poll with those two options (language or country contest) with arguments we offered why we think which option is better (in first post) because with conversations we obviously will never agree on this.
After this is decided, then other rules of contest can be discussed.
No one is saying that there's complete consensus right now, I'm completely aware of that. We still have to decide things for permanent good
A vote on the poll will definitely fix this issue
Please do a poll with those two options (language or country contest) with arguments we offered why we think which option is better (in first post) because with conversations we obviously will never agree on this.
After this is decided, then other rules of contest can be discussed.
r3gg13
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
No, this is a community venture, we will decide as a community. I'm here to ensure that.
No, this is a community venture, we will decide as a community. I'm here to ensure that.
SpZ
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
Now let's come back to the situation where people demanded that the rules would be equal for everyone. That also includes the way how you make the rules which principle you are asking to drop now.
Sorry to say it, but your 3rd sentence makes no sense at all and i do not understand even what you are trying to say.
Now let's come back to the situation where people demanded that the rules would be equal for everyone. That also includes the way how you make the rules which principle you are asking to drop now.
Sorry to say it, but your 3rd sentence makes no sense at all and i do not understand even what you are trying to say.
- Joined
- March 12, 2012
- Posts
- 23,033
doctormalisimo
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
There seems to be 2 camps here, those looking for a quick-fix solution to the FSC/NSC overcapacity problems and just want a new contest because they dislike the FSC/NSC rules, and those looking for a genuinely exciting, fresh, unique contest to discover music they never would have before. Take your pic.
I would if I found a song I love in itBut who will particiapte for Uzbek language?
Yes, that ^^
There seems to be 2 camps here, those looking for a quick-fix solution to the FSC/NSC overcapacity problems and just want a new contest because they dislike the FSC/NSC rules, and those looking for a genuinely exciting, fresh, unique contest to discover music they never would have before. Take your pic.
Grinch
Well-known member
- Joined
- March 13, 2011
- Posts
- 9,391
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
Do we have to eliminate one of them? Language Song Contest could be a spin-off of the main one.
Please do a poll with those two options (language or country contest) with arguments we offered why we think which option is better (in first post) because with conversations we obviously will never agree on this.
After this is decided, then other rules of contest can be discussed.
Do we have to eliminate one of them? Language Song Contest could be a spin-off of the main one.
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
TBH, Reggie - this topic is so tense, that we need a break
Grinch, Adel. On Topic please
TBH, Reggie - this topic is so tense, that we need a break
daniels1000
Well-known member
r3gg13
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
Let's get this cleared, at this point we are all equals in deciding the game. No one has any inherent advantage over another in deciding what game will happen, a vote will decide it for all of us.
I will set a poll, once people calm down a bit
Let's get this cleared, at this point we are all equals in deciding the game. No one has any inherent advantage over another in deciding what game will happen, a vote will decide it for all of us.
I will set a poll, once people calm down a bit
SpZ
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
a) the copy song contest could be a spin-off of the language song contest b) the concepts are fundamentally different. In one you have people base on language taking part in other based on countries. It wouldn't be like nsc or fsc where the same people would take part in spin-offs under the same nations. They simply have nothing to do with each other and would better be as 2 separate things than spin-offs of each other
a) the copy song contest could be a spin-off of the language song contest b) the concepts are fundamentally different. In one you have people base on language taking part in other based on countries. It wouldn't be like nsc or fsc where the same people would take part in spin-offs under the same nations. They simply have nothing to do with each other and would better be as 2 separate things than spin-offs of each other
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
If there is a poll, then it would be silly to post explanations which option is better - let the people decide!
Please do a poll with those two options (language or country contest) with arguments we offered why we think which option is better (in first post) because with conversations we obviously will never agree on this.
After this is decided, then other rules of contest can be discussed.
If there is a poll, then it would be silly to post explanations which option is better - let the people decide!
Hele.
Well-known member
- Joined
- April 3, 2011
- Posts
- 11,370
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
Yes, let people decide.
But let people to see why we are against/for some options. It is not explanation which option is better. That are arguments of both sides. What is bad if they shorty lear arguments about we are discussing? :?
Yes, let people decide.
But let people to see why we are against/for some options. It is not explanation which option is better. That are arguments of both sides. What is bad if they shorty lear arguments about we are discussing? :?
Grinch
Well-known member
- Joined
- March 13, 2011
- Posts
- 9,391
daniels1000
Well-known member
- Joined
- March 12, 2012
- Posts
- 23,033
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
If you choose this or that contest (by the poll) will be harmed the rights of those whose contest is not selected
The more supporters of the Language Contest participating in the FSC and the NSC, and satisfied them, but new contest for the dissatisfied
If you choose this or that contest (by the poll) will be harmed the rights of those whose contest is not selected
The more supporters of the Language Contest participating in the FSC and the NSC, and satisfied them, but new contest for the dissatisfied
SpZ
Well-known member
Re: Creating new contest on the forum
a) So why can't i decide it myself, but you have nothing against Grinch deciding it himself/herself. Screaming discrimination.
b) Spin-offs would have to have to share the same fundamental ideas with the main contest... like they do in fsc or nsc but wouldn't in the proposed new solutions.
a) So why can't i decide it myself, but you have nothing against Grinch deciding it himself/herself. Screaming discrimination.
b) Spin-offs would have to have to share the same fundamental ideas with the main contest... like they do in fsc or nsc but wouldn't in the proposed new solutions.