Contact us

United Kingdom UNITED KINGDOM 2018 - SuRie - Storm

How do you rate this entry?

  • 12

    13 5.5%
  • 10

    11 4.7%
  • 8

    10 4.3%
  • 7

    16 6.8%
  • 6

    24 10.2%
  • 5

    29 12.3%
  • 4

    30 12.8%
  • 3

    21 8.9%
  • 2

    24 10.2%
  • 1

    17 7.2%
  • 0

    40 17.0%

  • Total voters
    235

JonnyWest

Member
Joined
January 29, 2017
Posts
2,736
Location
Porto, Portugal
Not my favorite, who I thought was completely chanceless, actually winning this :lol:

Good for her xcheer the song is catchy as hell, anthemic even at some point, and you can easily sing-along but tbh I don't expect this to do very well

7 points
 

anto475

Well-known member
Joined
January 18, 2012
Posts
2,583
Location
Dublin/Galway
It wants to be Clean Bandit so bad
 

Brandt

Well-known member
Joined
December 27, 2014
Posts
3,203
Molly had a great song but she totally ruined her song at the Eurovision with her performance. SuRie can sing live much better but her song is weaker. Overall I am not expecting a worse result than 2014 this year for UK.

I am being a bit generous because I think the song will be a grower, and I am giving 7.
 

MyHeartIsYours

Well-known member
Joined
May 22, 2010
Posts
24,545
I didn't get home from work until Jazz's performance so had to watch the first performances using the shitty tram wifi... I've now watched them properly. Omg why the heck wasn't Liam selected he looked amazing, sounded amazing! o_O Holding out for a NUL POINTS with this Storm thingy tbh!

2008 and 2018 are my worst Eurovision years for the United Kingdom, what is it about the 8's?
 

Leydan

Super Moderator 🌴
Staff member
Joined
March 1, 2013
Posts
18,854
Location
UK
I didn't get home from work until Jazz's performance so had to watch the first performances using the shitty tram wifi... I've now watched them properly. Omg why the heck wasn't Liam selected he looked amazing, sounded amazing! o_O Holding out for a NUL POINTS with this Storm thingy tbh!

2008 and 2018 are my worst Eurovision years for the United Kingdom, what is it about the 8's?

Tbh I thought it was rather poor and forgettable, my family watched a long side me and they all totally switched off during his song. So that could have been a trend across others. I preferred his song in the studio version, but one of the weakest of the night.
 

JonnyWest

Member
Joined
January 29, 2017
Posts
2,736
Location
Porto, Portugal
I've just seen SuRie's live performance and I loved it! Simple but very honest and sincere, not pretending to be something else that it isn't, I hope this grows on other people and gets a good result in Lisbon xlove Oh and those people comparing this to Levina's ''Perfect Life'' please... she only whishes xqueenbitch

Changed to 10 points

Jaz did great as well! Would have been a very deserving winner also, I just wished the song had a bigger impact to match to quality of the singer's voice. I must have been in a bad day when I first heard the songs cause everything sounded better to me today, even that annoying girl group xheat
 

ZoboCamel

Well-known member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Posts
4,531
Location
Melbourne, Australia
I am being a bit generous because I think the song will be a grower

While that's entirely possible – and it's a perfectly fine reason to rate the song highly yourself – I'm not sure that it bodes well for the UK's score at Eurovision this year. When (one presumes) the large majority of televoters are casual audiences who haven't heard the songs before, growers don't really get the time to shine, and it more comes down to what can make the biggest impact on that first or second listen.
 

GWTW1939

Active member
Joined
March 10, 2013
Posts
4,951
Location
United States
Is there a reason why Asanda was singing solo and had no backing vocalists :?

Her vocals weren't good and shaky at best but they weren't unsalable. The backing vocalists could have easily picked up the slack and covered the rough patches. Backing singers doing the heavy lifting is hardly anything new at ESC you would think the BBC know that xfacepalm Those backing dancers were hardly doing any insane choreography, why couldn't they do backup? It would have made a far stronger impression xshrug
 

laululind

Well-known member
Joined
January 4, 2011
Posts
468
Very disappointing choice IMO, I only found Goldstone worse than this. :( Liked Asanda and Jaz best. Based on yesterday's performances, I would have gone for Jaz, but Asanda had potential and could have been fixed up for Eurovision. If not these two, I would have picked Liam or Raya.. both rather generic, but still less so than the eventual winner. :lol: Storm sounds like the definition of dated bland pop track for me, especially the chorus. She's a decent live performer, but even the best vocals in the world wouldn't save this song for me. I can't see it doing well at all come May, and I bet we'll get to hear about evil voting blocks and Brexit if UK flops again. :rolleyes: No, it's just the woefully generic and unremarkable song, not the fact the whole Europe hates you. :lol: Oh well, 3p for now, because at least it doesn't actively annoy me. Maybe a big revamp will help.
 

hijirio

Veteran
Joined
April 25, 2012
Posts
6,304
Location
Gay
Raya is so underrated :( It would have been my number one entry if chosen.
It's the best national final entry I heard this year.
Greta Salome does wonders, really.

Legends is also so nice, I wouldn't be mad at all if they chose her over Raya.
But UK made its chose and went for SuRie . .... ... . ... ..
The sad thing is, even revamp can't save it. They need to change the melody radically.
Nothing to do about it.

I hope they involve foreign votes next year.
No one outside UK seems to be interested in this entry.
 

theditz83

Veteran
Joined
February 7, 2010
Posts
20,616
Location
Scotland & Moisantia
Raya is so underrated :( It would have been my number one entry if chosen.
It's the best national final entry I heard this year.
Greta Salome does wonders, really.

Legends is also so nice, I wouldn't be mad at all if they chose her over Raya.
But UK made its chose and went for SuRie . .... ... . ... ..
The sad thing is, even revamp can't save it. They need to change the melody radically.
Nothing to do about it.

I hope they involve foreign votes next year.
No one outside UK seems to be interested in this entry.

Well they may have had some international jury members in the "panel of 8 experts" who were mysteriously anonymous, but I guess we'll never know. Honestly, why is it so hard to just announce scores like they do in Melfest or every other song contest worth anything? Even a "6th place goes to...., 5th place goes to...." would be better.

BBC wake up! We don't want 30 minutes of filler material that we've seen already or that makes us cringe (hello celebrity judges!) we want a proper tension building voting phase with each section of the UK represented and the judges votes separate. Please make it happen!
 

FilipFromSweden

Well-known member
Joined
March 27, 2012
Posts
6,667
SuRie seems like a darling, but that song is a big nothing. UK does this almost every year? It gets 2 points from me. Also are there no detailed results?
 

cripesdude

Active member
Joined
January 21, 2012
Posts
315
Well they may have had some international jury members in the "panel of 8 experts" who were mysteriously anonymous


Caroline Sullivan - Music Journalist, The Guardian

Roisin O'Connor - Music Correspondent, The Independent

Steve Tandy - Regional Radio Promoter

Sara Sesardic -Music Editor at Spotify

Alastair Webber - A&R Manager

Marco Sensi -Music Editor, MTV Music

(Head Judge) David Grant -Vocal Coach

Kele Le Roc -Artist, writer and creative

(http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/5srnyQSNsFPZ9xfNV6nZ5Nb/voting-eurovision-you-decide)
 

cripesdude

Active member
Joined
January 21, 2012
Posts
315
Having slept on this somewhat surprising result here are my thoughts:

The performances/songs
1. Reviewing the live performances I’m not surprised SuRie won. Her vocal was really good and her previous experience clearly made a difference. She has an arguably average song but delivered it perfectly; it was the most solid package.
2. Asanda winning was always contingent on the live performance working. It’s really frustrating but it didn’t. The studio version is absolutely standout, but the live staging fell short, and her constant movement resulted in breathy vocals - I always thought she would just be centre stage giving it all with her voice and giving some sass, with dancers and lights animating the stage. Her entry was very similar to Margaret’s ‘Cool Me Down’ and it suffered the same fate; perhaps this style of song just doesn’t work so well live?
3. Jaz was fantastic, but the song just wasn’t interesting enough. This isn’t to say this style of song couldn’t do well, but it needed more work and had to offer greater progression.
4. Likewise with Liam. He sang very well and the initial staging gave a good first impression, but the song needed to go further. SuRie had the edge here with more of an anthemic build.
5. Goldstone for me brought great vocals, but the song again needed work. It sounded dated and like well worn Little Mix and Girls Aloud songs had been stitched together; we need to innovate not emulate.
6. Raya for me suffered vocally. Much like Asanda her movement resulted in breathy vocals that distracted too much from the song which, whilst needing some work to differentiate the latter two minutes from the first, had potential.

The show/selection overall
1. The BBC need to rethink how the results are delivered. The lack of transparency is both highly questionable and it is very anti-climatic to just announce the winner. They need a budget for some on-screen graphics, and give us the jury results and then the televote results.
2. There needs to be thoughts about a foreign jury like many other national selections.
3. The format works overall. I just hope the BBC grow this: 10 songs instead of 6, a bigger stage, develop content beyond tours of the host city and throwbacks.
4. This was a good year. The finalists were all better than the first round of acts on Melodifestivalen, every performer was competent (I would be love to see any of them return), and overall the song selection (although entirely sitting within radio-friendly pop) was an improvement on previous years.

The winning entry
1. The UK has played it safe and gone with the best live package at this stage. I understand why, but am not sure if this is the best tactic. I think Asanda had way more potential, especially with a few months to work on the presentation (which is easier to change than a song), but you can’t blame anyone for going with the on-the-night performance.
2. A revamp might draw out the song’s Avicii aspects, giving it its best chance. At the moment it’s not commanding or current enough to really stand out and deliver as a memorable pop offering. The lyrics are also in need of some work, there's a fine line between being understood by non-English speakers and simply being poor.
3. SuRe will own this - she’ll sing well and surely work on the presentation/performance.


The wisdom of the crowd has spoken. Ultimately though, I feel if the UK wanted to contend the top ten a risk should have been taken with Asanda. I just don't see Storm as interesting enough to crack the left side of the scoreboard… but here I am hoping to eat my words, and my final verdict awaits any re-vamp and the final performance!
 

RomanFromRussia

Well-known member
Joined
April 24, 2011
Posts
6,992
Location
haus of esk flops
Wake me up when UK starts trying tbh.

The choice is actually dreadful, but not that disappointing. The selection was absolutely mess right from the start all the songs were contenders for bottom-7, and live-performances when all the potential of the songs was lost have just proved it. SuRie was the only one with at least decent performance.(There actually were Goldstone, but their song was a vocal-training). There is no surprise for me she was chosen, I don't care about UK during the Euroseason. SuRie seems to be a nice person, and she is a good performer as well, but song "Together-Forever-Remember" from the UK, ARE U HECKIN' SERIOUS?

I would be OK, if it was Malta, the country that has not such music industry that UK has. Considering the fact UK has such selections I don't want to see it in a Big-5. Maybe semifinals will change it as well.

Or maybe Australia was just invited just to show the UK what is possible in ESC? Anyway, there are more questions than answers. :lol:
 
Top Bottom