As every year there is a Eurovision Songcheck on eurovision.de in which 3 "experts" and the fans talk about the songs and rate them (from 0 to 10). These are the results of yesterdays show in which the first 10 songs were presented (with comments):
1
8,8/10
"fascinating voice" - "different/special" - "great" - "catchy tune" - "will reach the final without a doubt"
2
8,4/10
"good song" - "perfect fitting voices" - "radio-friendly but also something special" - "it's cool" - "retro with modern elements" - "will reach Top 10 but won't win because of the weak live-performance" - "too static"
3
7,6/10
"kind of exchangeable" - "sounds very Coldplay" - "camp-fire-romantic without fire" - "ok, something is missing" - "thoroughbred musicians" - "they should get rid of the burning piano"
4
6,6/10
"great hook" - "one would like to dance" - "a bit too repetitive" - "has no highlights" - "sounds good but a bit dated" - "strong and mature" - "strong women with a great voice" - "Final without a doubt"
5
6,15/10
"charming" - "good but not amazing" - "good singer/good voice" - "Macedonian-version was better then the English one" - "not bad but boring melody"
6
6/10
"the best Finish entry since 2006" - "great punk-rock" - "get's better and better with every listening" - "They love to make music. One can hear that" - "great lyrics"
7
5,6/10
"she has a great voice and is very beautiful" - "too much of everything" - "love the Spanish-lyrics" - "it's doesn't reach me/ emotionless"
8
4,5/10
"well meant but not well done" - "creative" - "too dramatic" - "people won't get the massage of the song" - "seems chaotic and unfinished"
9
3,6/10
"no emotions at all" - "beautiful ballad and great voice but something is missing" - "very constructed" - "too simple"
10
3,25/10
"good opener" - "not strong enough" - "not original" - "sounds a bit like karaoke"