Contact us

Austria AUSTRIA 2015 - The Makemakes - I Am Yours

How do you rate the entry?

  • 12

    34 19.7%
  • 10

    20 11.6%
  • 8

    23 13.3%
  • 7

    15 8.7%
  • 6

    18 10.4%
  • 5

    22 12.7%
  • 4

    7 4.0%
  • 3

    11 6.4%
  • 2

    6 3.5%
  • 1

    8 4.6%
  • 0

    9 5.2%

  • Total voters
    173

ParadiseES

Well-known member
Joined
October 3, 2009
Posts
15,047
Location
Zaragoza (Spain)
(P)review: First round of the Austrian NF (P)review: First round of the Austrian NF | ESCunited.com

My crappy cellphone picture of the stage
So yesterday I went to see the recording of Round 1 of the Austrian national final for 2015. Upon arriving at the ORF centre it’s immediately apparent which topic will be the dominating one in the upcoming months: Building Bridges logos and Conchita Wurst pictures wherever you look. And – being from a country that hasn’t exactly been a powerhouse in Eurovision – it still hasn’t completely sunk in that the city I live in is hosting the contest next year. But I’m slowly getting there.

The recording took no less than seven (!) hours. It was certainly a marathon for your gluteal muscles. 16 artists got to perform one of their songs in order to present themselves to the judges and the audience. Please note that these songs won’t be their actual NF entries.
Before we even got to see the first act, we had to record various types of clapping: normal, enthusiastic and hysterical applause. Ah, the merits of prerecorded television. After about 30 (okay, I might be exaggerating a little there) clapping attempts we finally moved on to the actual performances.
First up were the Makemakes with their feel-good song Million Euro Smile. I’d classify their music as catchy Indie pop. Great start – they definitely know how to perform!
Then we got to hear Tandem with Zeig ihn mir. Hmm, this one confused me a little – a weird mixture of Indie and Schlager which wasn’t really my cup of tea. They performed it competently though.
Kathi Kallauch sang her song Das Leben ist zu kurz. The main thing that stood out here was her really pleasant and soothing voice. The song itself was cute but rather on the boring side. I certainly saw some potential there though.
Clara Blume (Photo: ORF)
The band wo/Men had the glorious idea of covering Pharell William’s Happy. Because we totally hadn’t heard that song often enough already. Anyway, they did well and delivered a good performance. The act definitely lacked some kind of originality though.
Up next was the singer/songwriter Clara Blume. I was really pleased to see her being included in the line-up since I already discovered her great music some time ago. And this time – performing her song Love & Starve – she didn’t disappoint either.

Celina Ann went for Aretha Franklin’s song I Never Loved a Man. And she sang it really, really well. Despite the flawless vocals, everything seemed a little too polished and clinical – I missed some personality and charisma on stage.
If you’re into Austrian alternative music you’ve certainly stumbled upon Kommando Elefant before. They’re an established band in the scene and performed their song Mein Design fürs Leben this time. It’s quite hard to classify their style but I’d say… funky electropop meets Indie pop?
Lemo performed his calm song So leicht. It wasn’t exactly exciting but definitely very nice. But you know what they say about ‘nice’.
In order to keep the audience entertained in the breaks between the songs, we got to listen to some of the greatest moments in the history of music: everything from Barbie Girl to YMCA. To my great joy, all artists got to play their instruments live – which explains the long breaks between the acts.



My personal highlight was the band Renato Unterberg with their song Love. And wow, the lead singer Renato is one hell of a performer! There was something very Tom Waits and edgy about the whole thing. Great discovery!
Next up we had the band The Su’sis and they came on stage with their very pleasant Swing song This and That. It would be really interesting to see this kind of song in Eurovision.
DAWA is another band I’ve already known for quite a while. With their song On the Run they managed to create a really intimate and cozy atmosphere on stage – including some glockenspiel action! A personal favourite of mine!
Johann Sebastian Bass (Photo: ORF)
Then we had Johann Sebastian Bach. The name says it all: they perform with Baroque wigs and have this crazy mixture of 17th century classical music and electropop going on. Despite not being the best singers, their performance of Heart of Stone was really kick-ass.
Fancy some traditional Austrian folk music? Then Folkshilfe might be your kind of thing. In their song Seit a poa Tog they mixed it with Reggae elements which sounded interesting but it didn’t really work for me.
A big positive surprise was the just 18-year-old singer Zoe. She performed her catchy song Adieu – a combination of electro-swing and French chanson. And she did really well at selling it!
The wackiest act was definitely Mizgebonez. They brought two desks and turned the stage into an office. With a medley of their songs Murmeltier and Fitnesstraining (for which they literally started working out on stage) they really got the crowd going. Regarding the genre: I really can’t put my finger on it but let’s just say they are a way better version of Trackshittaz.
Last but not least we had the rap trio Royal Kombo with their Reggae-influenced song Ram Pam Pam. I pretty liked this one even though it wasn’t too exciting in the end.
So that was it. On the whole, I’m really pleased with what ORF has put together. The scouting team managed to pick some great undiscovered talents plus some experienced artists you’d never expect to see in anything Eurovision-related. The line-up was diverse and mostly high-quality. The only thing I’m rather sceptical about is the whole thing about the coaches – the vast majority of these artists seems independent enough to do their own thing. But we’ll see how they’ll be approaching it.
Then we were just waiting for the results. Perfect opportunity to record some clapping again, yay! The jury was made up of various music industry professionals, 2007 participant Eric Papilaya (wow, ORF really pulled out the big guns with that one…) and the Austrian ESC commentator Andi Knoll. Their task was to cut down the line-up to just 6 artists. Quite a tough job I must say. The 6 qualifiers will get to present themselves in the next few shows and work on two potential songs for Eurovision.
Then we moved on to the results. Exciting moments. They kept telling us not to reveal anything to the public. I’ll respect that and keep my mouth shut until the first round gets aired in February. After all, it would be unfair towards the competing artists who possibly want to promote themselves as national final participants.
All in all, this was certainly a fun experience and I’m already looking forward to the second show next week!

The content of this editorial does not necessarily reflect the opinions and views of ESC United, its editorial board or its readers.
 

RainyWoods

Croak-kay
Joined
February 9, 2012
Posts
25,730
Location
London
I was patiently waiting for you to share your opinions [MENTION=4386]anselm[/MENTION] :p


"My personal highlight was the band Renato Unterberg with their song Love. And wow, the lead singer Renato is one hell of a performer! There was something very Tom Waits and edgy about the whole thing. Great discovery!"

Yes, yes.. YESYESYES YESxheat

I'm so hyped for Renato, it's unbelievable. I purchased his new album and absolutely love it. I knew he'd be an incredible performer. He seems to ooze something special. Without even hearing the song, I just feel he is going to deliver.... that is if he is allowed full control of EVERYTHING. As you say, these artists don't need to be coached. They don't need to have songs written for them. Why go through the trouble of finding a bunch of artistic alternative artists if you're going to treat them like desperate teenagers? Coaching is ridiculous.
 

anselm

Well-known member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
8,849
Location
Vienna
And apparently he has 3 albums out already :eek: I'm definitely going to listen to some of his stuff too.

About the coaching: yeah, the idea is ridiculous. But I'm positive it won't be too bad. Anna F said in an interview that it won't be like in a typical casting show but rather working together on an equal level. But we'll see.
 

RainyWoods

Croak-kay
Joined
February 9, 2012
Posts
25,730
Location
London
And apparently he has 3 albums out already :eek: I'm definitely going to listen to some of his stuff too.

Yeah, I only spotted one of them for sale though. I got it for £4.00 from emusic. I'm really surprised their music hasn't garnered any attention until now. He has a minuscule amount of listeners on lastfm.


About the coaching: yeah, the idea is ridiculous. But I'm positive it won't be too bad. Anna F said in an interview that it won't be like in a typical casting show but rather working together on an equal level. But we'll see.

Still I don't like or get it though. Generally a good artist is a free person, they choose who they work with, not the other way round. I don't understand fully how everything works but what is a coach supposed to tell someone who already has found themselves as an artist, knows completely who they are and what they're about, and has honed their craft? Working on an equal level is still ridiculous. I'd be furious if someone had any say in the artistic direction I take.
 

Mlyn

Banned
Joined
March 19, 2014
Posts
2,261
Location
.at
[MENTION=4386]anselm[/MENTION]: Are you happy with the 6 qualifiers or is there one or another candidate left of whom you would be scared of going to ESC?

btw. any chance I can get a press accreditation for next ESC?
 

Mlyn

Banned
Joined
March 19, 2014
Posts
2,261
Location
.at
I also think Renato Unterberg would be the best choice, but only with "Love".

Looks and sounds very promising....

Johann Sebastian Bass have a great tune in Heart of Stone, but their appearance (make up / costumes) is a bit too tacky and depreciates their credibility. Their have been better songs already on last place like Waldos People or Twin Twin.
 

anselm

Well-known member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
8,849
Location
Vienna
[MENTION=4386]anselm[/MENTION]: Are you happy with the 6 qualifiers or is there one or another candidate left of whom you would be scared of going to ESC?

Well, there were both big yay and nay moments in the results... But I'm very happy with 4/6 qualifiers.
 

marty

Well-known member
Joined
December 6, 2014
Posts
1,812
@ anselm thank you so much for your review!

i live in vienna but i have not been at the show. i must say that this years austrian nf is very promising. it is difficult to predict the 6 finalists since there are so many things that must be considered like to find artists of different styles, mixture of bands and male/ female solo artists (difficult since there are so many female solo artists) and acts that fit to the three coaches. also it is to keep in mind that parts of the jury have different interests not only to vote what they think would be the best act for esc.

and that is the reason why i am quite sure that it will not be the 6 best acts, because the 5 best acts are very similar - singer/ songwriter ore indie/ elctronic style bands like "dawa", "renato unterberg", "johann sebastian bass", "the makemakes" and "kommando elefant".
i think that any of these bands would be a perfect choice to represent austria at the esc (depending on the song of course), all of them could make it without the help of coaches or international composers.

who must be among the finalist in my opinion is "renato unterberg" and "dawa", and i guess another one of the above mentioned.

then there will be a "new face" - i would say "Zoe", maybe "Celina Ann".

there will be an act that fits to coach "Nazar" - either "Mizgebonez" or "Royal Kombo".

and there will be for sure one act in german language - either "Folkshilfe", "Lemo" or "Kathi Kallauch"

i dont quite understand why "tandem" have been chosen. i fear that they have a special connection to anyone involved and make it this way into the final.... but hope i am wrong.

i guess that it was already clear who the 6 finalists will be before the show started. maybe they also knew some of the potential songs and included that into their decision.

however i hope that it will not be revealed before 20 february because the guessing and discussing is one of the most fun parts of the whole esc.

i just registered today, this was my first post. i am glad i found this forum!
 

anselm

Well-known member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
8,849
Location
Vienna
Welcome [MENTION=14099]marty[/MENTION]! :mrgreen: Very well analysed - I wish I could make a proper reply to that. :p
 

Mlyn

Banned
Joined
March 19, 2014
Posts
2,261
Location
.at
I hope Tandem and wo/Man are out.....
 

Leydan

Super Moderator 🌴
Staff member
Joined
March 1, 2013
Posts
18,869
Location
UK

Conchita on The Graham Norton Show last night. :D
 

Mlyn

Banned
Joined
March 19, 2014
Posts
2,261
Location
.at
Graham Norton seems to have a crush on gorgeous Conchita, but who hasnt?

He's still a horrible commentator, even worse than Terry Wogan....:(
 

Leydan

Super Moderator 🌴
Staff member
Joined
March 1, 2013
Posts
18,869
Location
UK
Graham Norton seems to have a crush on gorgeous Conchita, but who hasnt?

He's still a horrible commentator, even worse than Terry Wogan....:(

you think hes worse? I think he is a hell of a lot better than Terry. Yes he does joke about but he never intentionally insults countries and their acts like Terry did. Graham tries to play a more neutral role and gives his opinions lightly, whereas Terry just point black said if he hated it or not. Then threw a fit when we gave the song he hated points. Terry is the reason so many eastern European countries will never (or very rarely) get points of us. The only eastern countries who do get points of us are those with a significant minority over here.
 

Mlyn

Banned
Joined
March 19, 2014
Posts
2,261
Location
.at
I find both of them very insulting and I get very upset when I watch the BBC versions of Eurovision votings.

Terry was more going after block voting and going after Eastern Europe (he really seems to be a hater of Slavic people) and Graham is going after spokespersons, especially after French but also Eastern Europe. "That means a lot coming from you", "She speaks very good French", "Oh look, it's the Eiffel tower, I almost forgot it's there"... at least he got to taste his own flavour when Pilou Asbaek took on him live in front of entire Europe

BBC acts very divisive imho, the old superior Europe with UK on its throne, and nasty Eastern Europe in the backyard. And UK jury also votes very divisive....
 

theCONWEL

WorldVision Mod 🍁
Staff member
Joined
August 9, 2011
Posts
10,237
Location
Birmingham, UK
I just think Graham's commentary is very tailored to British comedy and the attitudes to Eurovision in this country...
 

Carrie

Active member
Joined
December 29, 2014
Posts
3,548
[MENTION=13474]Mlyn[/MENTION] I think saying the UK jury votes divisive is unfair, using this year as an example 6/10 countries that were in the top 10 are western; the 'best' songs got ranked highly and that came out in the overall result. Also, individual jury members ranked nations like Ukraine, Azerbaijan, Belarus and Slovenia highly.

Even last years results had a random trend - here are the grand final top 10 from the jury.

1. Russia

2. Belgium

3. Denmark

4. Estonia

5. Ukraine

6. The Netherlands

7. Georgia

8. Belarus

9. Azerbaijan

10. Iceland

If that's not spread I don't know what is. The UK of all countries is definitely not involved in any dodgy voting compared to a few other places.
 

Mlyn

Banned
Joined
March 19, 2014
Posts
2,261
Location
.at
I hope to see Klangkarussell as an interval show act this year or as a competing act in the near future.
They won an EBBA award and achieved a number one in :nl: and many Top 3 in Western European countries. In February their album is going to be released in the States.


That's my favourite video and song by them:
 
Top Bottom