Contact us

THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - MONTENEGRO

EurovisionSmile
portugal

EurovisionSmile

Veteran
Joined
February 24, 2010
Posts
24,126
Location
Lisbon & Kordavian Islands
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

Peiku said:
I see, thanks for letting me know. Your arguments really convinced me. Instead of having a panel review and rate all songs, we should simply ask you. "Sweden? 45 points!"
Click to expand...

No, the panel review is fine it's just you who seems kinda annoying :lol:
 
EurovisionSmile
portugal

EurovisionSmile

Veteran
Joined
February 24, 2010
Posts
24,126
Location
Lisbon & Kordavian Islands
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

But forgetting the self-proclaimed 'genius' for a while, I give :se: 5 points. A great performance that makes this song special.
 
Mozz
netherlands

Mozz

Well-known member
Joined
February 23, 2011
Posts
11,249
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

Sheep33.png
 
oullaxerista
cyprus

oullaxerista

Member
Joined
January 29, 2012
Posts
216
Location
Paphos
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

One of the best songs this year....Definitely a winning song...:D
 

Peiku

Guest
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

Nike said:
Loool, this is not only about Sweden. What about the ridiculous score to Iceland? Only 3 to Serbia??
Click to expand...
So you don't agree with (some of) my ratings. So what? It's just natural that you won't achieve consensus between all members of the forum on each of the 42 entries. Just look at the "angry mob" votes, for every single song you will find scores ranging from 0 to 5.

And you only talked about Netherlands costume not about the song at all??

Strange, you compared Loreen to Kate Bush but nothing about Nina Zilli a la AMY WINEHOUSE...
Click to expand...

Again, I can't possibly cover all aspects of a performance in the review. But what I can do is trying to take as much as possible into account when rating an entry. The rating is not based on the review. Nor is the review necessary based on the rating, as a matter of fact.

Then you hype Italy and their boring singer. BTW Nina's Zillis live performances are so terrible weak. Sweden's entry is way more original than Italy's.
Click to expand...

That's your opinion. My opinion differs from yours.

May I ask you: Are you from Italy? I think youy put down the other faves just to put up Italy in the rankings.
Click to expand...

Nope, I'm not from Italy, and I can assure you that I take my job seriously and when judging the songs I'm as impartial and unbiased as I can be.
 
Nike
denmark

Nike

Active member
Joined
December 23, 2009
Posts
638
Location
STHLM
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

Peiku said:
So you don't agree with (some of) my ratings. So what? It's just natural that you won't achieve consensus between all members of the forum on each of the 42 entries. Just look at the "angry mob" votes, for every single song you will find scores ranging from 0 to 5.



Again, I can't possibly cover all aspects of a performance in the review. But what I can do is trying to take as much as possible into account when rating an entry. The rating is not based on the review. Nor is the review necessary based on the rating, as a matter of fact.



That's your opinion. My opinion differs from yours.



Nope, I'm not from Italy, and I can assure you that I take my job seriously and when judging the songs I'm as impartial and unbiased as I can be.
Click to expand...

So explain the low rankings for the other faves, escpecially Sweden? BTW, you still haven't explain why you haven't compared Zilli to Winehouse when you compared Loreen to Kate Bush. Today it's worse to copy Winehouse than Bush since Winehouse were active as artist to her death.

It's strange that Sweden who get top scores everywhere now suddenly get a 2 from you. Especially when you gave low points to other faves as Serbia and Iceland.

Yes, it's YOUR opinion. Why should we take it seriously when you give 2 points to a entry that most people give top scores??

This is also why I dislike this type of threads because it depends on few peoples opinions.

But I'm not surprised. This is how this forum works. Sweden is being put down because it's Sweden and because we are the favorite. It's prety sad.
 

Peiku

Guest
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

Well, as a sea otter I often have to "swim against the steam" ;)
 

Admin1

Member
Joined
March 6, 2012
Posts
86
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

It appears Tommy's vote is considered controversial. Let me give you this present to tame your anger.


2mzfv2x.jpg
 

Arun

Member
Joined
March 6, 2012
Posts
88
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

Mozz said:
Sheep33.png
Click to expand...

You seem pissed off that the judges don't agree with you. Maybe you should apply next year since you think we are just a bunch of sheep.

I can also confirm I have never even touched an iphone before :p
 
LalehForWD
sweden

LalehForWD

Active member
Joined
March 21, 2012
Posts
7,788
Location
Sweden
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

I think Mozz is just shamelessly rooting for ... what could it be ...
The Netherlands :mrgreen::D:lol:xlolxoscar
 
dezbee2008
united_states

dezbee2008

Well-known member
Joined
March 8, 2012
Posts
2,277
Location
Florida
Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SWEDEN

5 points. It's so good.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom