Creating new contests on the forum

[Grinch]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

Voted.

I still don't get how is this contest different from NSC and FSC, it will eventually end up with too many members and it will have the same problems as NSC and FSC.

1 - If too many members participate, there will be semi finals.
2 - Everyone can be a member of whatever jury they want.
3 - No waiting.

 

[Luki]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

I do not think so. But as I said, nothing prevents create 1-2-3-4-5-6 semifinals, because each participant will participate in his semifinal and final. And more than 206 countries can not be (does not exist more)

The thing that I still can't understand is how the juries will be functioning. You said there will be language juries, and that only one song per jury can got through the next phase. I'm completely lost.

 

[Luki]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

Voted.




2 - Everyone can be a member of whatever jury they want.

That's the problem! Only one song per jury which means there will be members that won't get their turn with certain song from some jury.

 

[AdelAdel]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

That's the problem! Only one song per jury which means there will be members that won't get their turn with certain song from some jury.

They will have to take turns, that's why I suggested the maximum 3 people jury. If we're gonna have 10 people in a jury, then you will have to wait ages to send your favorite song.

 

[Trece]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

The thing that I still can't understand is how the juries will be functioning. You said there will be language juries, and that only one song per jury can got through the next phase. I'm completely lost.

NO!!! I against it. I want base on countries. Members can be in jury of any country (no matter where you live) So therefore, you can choose not only the Croatian jury (as in FSC), and any (Nigeria, Chile, Japan or Belgium)

 

[Trece]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

That's the problem! Only one song per jury which means there will be members that won't get their turn with certain song from some jury.

And if the jury will be Language, it will have to wait even longer, because, for example, in the English jury will be songs from the USA, UK, Canada, Australia and other English-speaking countries

 

[Grinch]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

The thing that I still can't understand is how the juries will be functioning. You said there will be language juries, and that only one song per jury can got through the next phase. I'm completely lost.

If there are more than 1 member in the jury, there will be national finals like in FSC. Everyone will send 1/2 song, one song will be chosen in the end. Or however they want to choose their entry.

That's the problem! Only one song per jury which means there will be members that won't get their turn with certain song from some jury.

Those rules are for the crowded juries. So many people will want to be in UK, USA juries. I'd prefer to be alone so I'm gonna choose interesting, underrated countries for example.

 

[Trece]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

Those rules are for the crowded juries. So many people will want to be in UK, USA juries. I'd prefer to be alone so I'm gonna choose interesting, underrated countries.

I'm sure the USA and UK jury the will not be a lot more people than in other countries.
I also go to those countries that are not yet represented in FSC, to acquaint people with their music.

 

[Luki]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

If there are more than 1 member in the jury, there will be national finals like in FSC. Everyone will send 1/2 song, one song will be chosen in the end. Or however they want to choose their entry.

That being said it would mean that not all participants will be able to send their song in other words it would be FSC with possibility of choosing juries. Nothing new.

Those rules are for the crowded juries. So many people will want to be in UK, USA juries. I'd prefer to be alone so I'm gonna choose interesting, underrated countries for example.

Again that is a problem since most of members will try to compete with mainstream artists and groups often hailing from USA and UK.

 

[Mozz]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

So the main difference between FSc and CCC is that you choose which country you want. You sort of 'sign a contract' for for example 6 months to be that country's jury.

 

[Luki]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

So the main difference between FSc and CCC is that you choose which country you want. You sort of 'sign a contract' for for example 6 months to be that country's jury.

Again it's like starting FSC over again. This would probably lead to many withdrawals in FSC.

 

[Mozz]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

That being said it would mean that not all participants will be able to send their song in other words it would be FSC with possibility of choosing juries. Nothing new.



Again that is a problem since most of members will try to compete with mainstream artists and groups often hailing from USA and UK.

1. see my previous post. It will be different from FSC

2. That's a prejudice. We don't know if that will happen. And if it happens, then what is the exact reason not to start the game? I'd say: so what?

In FSC, USA and UK don't win so often. Not as often as you would normally expect

 

[Grinch]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

That being said it would mean that not all participants will be able to send their song in other words it would be FSC with possibility of choosing juries. Nothing new.

Again, if they choose crowded juries. It can only be avoided by "1 member for each jury" option winnning which I don't support much. In this contest, the main purpose is to be in the jury whatever you want. Sending an entry, voting etc. is inside jury business.

And In FSC some countries don't even have their own jury. Don't compare.

Again that is a problem since most of members will try to compete with mainstream artists and groups often hailing from USA and UK.

How is that a problem? They can send whatever they want.

 

[Luki]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

1. see my previous post. It will be different from FSC

2. That's a prejudice. We don't know if that will happen. And if it happens, then what is the exact reason not to start the game? I'd say: so what?

In FSC, USA and UK don't win so often. Not as often as you would normally expect

I want this to happen, and also I want FSC to be ended once and for all. After this being started I bet there won't be much interest for FSC.

How is that a problem? They can send whatever they want.

It's a serious problem because 10 members may be left without chances if there's let's say 11 in USA jury. 1 goes through the other 10 is left with nothing. There shouldn't be any NF's and stuff, first one to send an entry for some jury will participate and the others should search for another song/jury.

 

[doctormalisimo]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

In FSC, USA and UK don't win so often. Not as often as you would normally expect

Well the USA jury have the decency not to select megastars lie Rihanna, Gaga etc every month and send more alternative, unknown artists

 

[Mozz]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

Well the USA jury have the decency not to select megastars lie Rihanna, Gaga etc every month and send more alternative, unknown artists

Frankly I wish they would. Do you think they would do well?

 

[AdelAdel]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

Frankly I wish they would. Do you think they would do well?

This is one thing that really shocked me about NSC - almost every country sends unknown artists

 

[Trece]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

It's a serious problem because 10 members may be left without chances if there's let's say 11 in USA jury. 1 goes through the other 10 is left with nothing. There shouldn't be any NF's and stuff, first one to send an entry for some jury will participate and the others should search for another song/jury.

The big difference: in FSC if you are a resident of the United States, you can not select another jury, and you have to put up with it. In our game you can choose any other jury, and be the boss in it

 

[Yoni]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

How can you be the boss of it if there can be more than 1 player per jury?

 

[Trece]

Re: New Contest: Voting Form #1

How can you be the boss of it if there can be more than 1 player per jury?

I see 10 members of the jury in Nigeria or Tibet. joke
It's your right to either be a member of the jury, or to choose a country which is not represented at the contest and be boss in it (over 200)