blue00eyes
Well-known member
Re: POLAND 2018
I hope it won't be Krajowe Eliminacje again. I don't think it does work.
I hope it won't be Krajowe Eliminacje again. I don't think it does work.
Poland POLAND 2018 - Gromee ft. Lukas Meijer - Light Me Up
- Thread starter escYOUnited
- Start date
- Watchers 16
JonnyWest
Member
Re: POLAND 2018
Festival da Canção didn't work for Portugal also and look what happened
The only thing you need is the perfect song
Festival da Canção didn't work for Portugal also and look what happened
The only thing you need is the perfect song
simonPL
Well-known member
- Joined
- April 28, 2014
- Posts
- 1,035
Re: POLAND 2018
^
Yes, but we need a change in decision making team as well. Regardless of a way of selection (internal choice or national final). Because with the current team there is a big chance that a perfect existing song will be not even considered.
^
Yes, but we need a change in decision making team as well. Regardless of a way of selection (internal choice or national final). Because with the current team there is a big chance that a perfect existing song will be not even considered.
Re: POLAND 2018
1. Well written song. Well produced song.
2. We need to get rid of the no-name 'stars' in the jury.
3. Talented singer who can sing live.
4. Likeable performer, so people are excited to back him/her up.
Overall this years preselections showed we have something there - like Carmell who was my favourite and still is on my playlist.
As long as we keep sending quality songs and singers (and Kasia WAS imo a quality singer, with weak song unfortunately) we will be fine.
1. Well written song. Well produced song.
2. We need to get rid of the no-name 'stars' in the jury.
3. Talented singer who can sing live.
4. Likeable performer, so people are excited to back him/her up.
Overall this years preselections showed we have something there - like Carmell who was my favourite and still is on my playlist.
As long as we keep sending quality songs and singers (and Kasia WAS imo a quality singer, with weak song unfortunately) we will be fine.
Patrycja
Member
- Joined
- May 8, 2014
- Posts
- 5
Re: POLAND 2018
So simple and so hard to do. When I first heard Kasia I thought it was a good, powerful and dark ballad with potential... But after few times the song was very irritating. The sound, the voice. Those are of course my remarks. But juries are not ok as well. I mean especially many points to Moldova (typical provincial music like popular in Poland disco polo). With 'Flashlight' the 21st place was a good place after I thought we stay in semi.
Next year I'd like to see something energetic, but professional. Unfortunately I don't even know which of young vocalists and bands are popular now.
Festival da Canção didn't work for Portugal also and look what happened
The only thing you need is the perfect song
So simple and so hard to do. When I first heard Kasia I thought it was a good, powerful and dark ballad with potential... But after few times the song was very irritating. The sound, the voice. Those are of course my remarks. But juries are not ok as well. I mean especially many points to Moldova (typical provincial music like popular in Poland disco polo). With 'Flashlight' the 21st place was a good place after I thought we stay in semi.
Next year I'd like to see something energetic, but professional. Unfortunately I don't even know which of young vocalists and bands are popular now.
blue00eyes
Well-known member
Re: POLAND 2018
simonPL
Well-known member
- Joined
- April 28, 2014
- Posts
- 1,035
Re: POLAND 2018
Margaret would be a great choice, but she is not interested in ESC anymore. Her new single "What You Do" will be released worldwide anyway, so I think she is focusing on her career without Eurovison, but maybe she will change her mind someday.
Disco-polo? I wouldn't compare it to Moldova, because Moldova is still well produced.
I think D-P would slay like Montenegro this year or Pertti Kurikan Nimipäivät from Finland in 2015.
Anyway, I hope we won't be never forced to check that on the ESC stage.
JUST NO.
Margaret would be a great choice, but she is not interested in ESC anymore. Her new single "What You Do" will be released worldwide anyway, so I think she is focusing on her career without Eurovison, but maybe she will change her mind someday.
Disco-polo? I wouldn't compare it to Moldova, because Moldova is still well produced.
I think D-P would slay like Montenegro this year or Pertti Kurikan Nimipäivät from Finland in 2015.
Anyway, I hope we won't be never forced to check that on the ESC stage.
blue00eyes
Well-known member
Re: POLAND 2018
Disco-polo would give us a Szpak result. Low with juries as always and high with televote. I really start to believe in this tbh.
Disco-polo would give us a Szpak result. Low with juries as always and high with televote. I really start to believe in this tbh.
jimijoop
Banned
- Joined
- October 8, 2016
- Posts
- 199
Re: POLAND 2018
Disco polo is good for parties but this genre is very unsuitable for Eurovision.
Poland sends Disco Polo at Eurovision it's like Bulgaria sends Chalga, Germany sends Schlager, Romania sends Manele, Serbia sends Turbofolk etc
Also the juries don't like these type of songs.
At least Moldova had decent radiofriendly dance song.
Disco polo is good for parties but this genre is very unsuitable for Eurovision.
Poland sends Disco Polo at Eurovision it's like Bulgaria sends Chalga, Germany sends Schlager, Romania sends Manele, Serbia sends Turbofolk etc
Also the juries don't like these type of songs.
At least Moldova had decent radiofriendly dance song.
SaladBreak
Well-known member
- Joined
- January 9, 2016
- Posts
- 3,506
Re: POLAND 2018
I hope Cleo returns in 2018 xcrossed
I hope Cleo returns in 2018 xcrossed
CaraMia
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 17, 2012
- Posts
- 946
Re: POLAND 2018
Another one for disco polo here! It would be so unexpected in a good way. And it reminds me somehow of pimba music. Portuguese people would be like "Is this Polish pimba???" and they would love it! Also, it's very catchy and the televote would vote for it for sure!
Another one for disco polo here! It would be so unexpected in a good way. And it reminds me somehow of pimba music. Portuguese people would be like "Is this Polish pimba???" and they would love it! Also, it's very catchy and the televote would vote for it for sure!
blue00eyes
Well-known member
Re: POLAND 2018
Yes, the greatest disco-polo hit
Yes, the greatest disco-polo hit
Alaska49
Well-known member
- Joined
- April 18, 2013
- Posts
- 2,895
Re: POLAND 2018
poland can absolutely do well with juries if they succeed at playing that game. this year was the first time they even tried to since their comeback and like, flashlight was a boring oversung mess, so the juries understandably went "no thanks".
poland can absolutely do well with juries if they succeed at playing that game. this year was the first time they even tried to since their comeback and like, flashlight was a boring oversung mess, so the juries understandably went "no thanks".
A-lister
Veteran
- Joined
- December 28, 2009
- Posts
- 32,825
Re: POLAND 2018
Well, Poland has two major obstacles in ESC...
...the first one is obviously with TVP that are clueless about how to handle this, they did it right in 2014 but since then we got one lame amateur ballad after the other (and no, I'm not saying they are lame because they are ballads, simply they are lame because they are badly produced, boring, messy and/-or dated). The National Selection is a big mess just like it was when the concept was used before the come back, simply a bunch of amateurs with an amateur show and songs that all sounds like they're demos. TVP really need to re-think this, I think they should have the mindset as in 2014 and as Bulgaria currently has, to really try to find and convince popular acts with hit songs to take part and choose internally, because none of them would want to humiliate themselves by taking part in the awful national selection show only to loose out to something worse (hello Margaret!) and that's one of the reasons the national final is filled with a bunch of no-name amateurs.
The second obstacle is the obvious bias from the juries in ESC that are systematically and purposely voting down Poland, surely the low quality entries don't help, but it's not as if Poland is always in the bottom bunch as the juries think (I'd say more in the middle), so there's something fishy here aswell, it was certainly apparent in 2014 and 2016, but also the other years.
Well, Poland has two major obstacles in ESC...
...the first one is obviously with TVP that are clueless about how to handle this, they did it right in 2014 but since then we got one lame amateur ballad after the other (and no, I'm not saying they are lame because they are ballads, simply they are lame because they are badly produced, boring, messy and/-or dated). The National Selection is a big mess just like it was when the concept was used before the come back, simply a bunch of amateurs with an amateur show and songs that all sounds like they're demos. TVP really need to re-think this, I think they should have the mindset as in 2014 and as Bulgaria currently has, to really try to find and convince popular acts with hit songs to take part and choose internally, because none of them would want to humiliate themselves by taking part in the awful national selection show only to loose out to something worse (hello Margaret!) and that's one of the reasons the national final is filled with a bunch of no-name amateurs.
The second obstacle is the obvious bias from the juries in ESC that are systematically and purposely voting down Poland, surely the low quality entries don't help, but it's not as if Poland is always in the bottom bunch as the juries think (I'd say more in the middle), so there's something fishy here aswell, it was certainly apparent in 2014 and 2016, but also the other years.
A-lister
Veteran
- Joined
- December 28, 2009
- Posts
- 32,825
Re: POLAND 2018
The juries would kill Poland if sending disco-polo, on the other hand the juries hate Poland regardless of what they send, I'm pretty sure a song like this would fair better than most Polish entries, in fact this (and the "better" disco polo songs) are better than 90% of what Poland sent to Eurovision so far so... which probably says more about the quality of Polish ESC entries but still
The juries would kill Poland if sending disco-polo, on the other hand the juries hate Poland regardless of what they send, I'm pretty sure a song like this would fair better than most Polish entries, in fact this (and the "better" disco polo songs) are better than 90% of what Poland sent to Eurovision so far so... which probably says more about the quality of Polish ESC entries but still
blue00eyes
Well-known member
Re: POLAND 2018
Who even is she ? We want famous people!
Sylwia Grzeszczak will do Eurovision someday maybe, she said that in an interview yesterday With a ballad.
Who even is she ? We want famous people!
Sylwia Grzeszczak will do Eurovision someday maybe, she said that in an interview yesterday
With a ballad.