Contact us

NSC Chat Box

Luki

Well-known member
Joined
March 6, 2011
Posts
15,185
Location
Zagreb
:es: 7-7 :de: (Aldapan Gora - Yindy)
:ge: 11-3 :ua: (Welcome to Racha - 19 86)
:be: 7-7 :at: (Mega Mindy Tijd - Queen of Queer)
:sl: 5-9 :hu: (Insane - Pók)
 

dogmeat

Well-known member
Joined
January 28, 2010
Posts
6,478
:es: 7-8 :de: (Aldapan Gora - Yindy)
:ge: 12-3 :ua: (Welcome to Racha - 19 86)
:be: 8-7 :at: (Mega Mindy Tijd - Queen of Queer)
:sl: 6-9 :hu: (Insane - Pók)
 

doctormalisimo

Well-known member
Joined
March 16, 2011
Posts
14,669
Location
Ireland/Scotland
And we have now reached the semi-finals

:de: 0-0 :ge: (Yindy - Welcome To Racha)
:be: 0-0 :hu: (Mega Mindy Tijd - Pók)

Deadline again will be when the semi finals of Euro 2024 finish (10 July ~23 CEST)
 

Sean

Admin
Staff member
Joined
September 28, 2009
Posts
17,237
Location
Calgary
Honoured to have a winner in this incredible final four xrose

:de: 2-3 :ge: (Yindy - Welcome To Racha)
:be: 3-2 :hu: (Mega Mindy Tijd - Pók)
 

Rmetr0

Well-known member
Joined
August 5, 2018
Posts
1,501
p.s. I wish, Yindy vs Welcome to Racha was a final match, but oh well... first Racha was against Srpski Rode and now against Yindy, and i had to not vote for this great entry two times 🙈
 

dogmeat

Well-known member
Joined
January 28, 2010
Posts
6,478
I asked ChatGPT to review Rumia's NSC playlist, and it didn't hold back


Rumia’s musical style is a chaotic mess of disjointed genres and misplaced ambitions, revealing a lack of coherent identity or focus. Their choices come off as a desperate attempt to please everyone, resulting in a jumbled hodgepodge that fails to excel in any single area.

Folk and Ethnic Influences​

Rumia’s obsession with folk and ethnic music is almost laughable. Bands like Korpiklaani and The Moon and the Nightspirit churn out the same tired old folk tunes dressed up with a “modern twist” that feels anything but fresh. The overuse of traditional instruments and melodies by Żywiołak and Rapalje reeks of a forced connection to cultural roots, more like an awkward costume party than genuine artistry.

Symphonic and Orchestral Elements​

The symphonic and orchestral selections in Rumia's playlist seem like a failed attempt to add a veneer of sophistication. Nightwish and Within Temptation, with their overblown, operatic pretensions, come across as trying too hard to be epic. The inclusion of Hans Zimmer and Howard Shore, whose work is ubiquitous in every wannabe-epic playlist, only highlights Rumia's lack of originality and reliance on safe, mainstream choices. The video game soundtracks by Jeremy Soule and Gareth Coker add nothing but more clichés to the mix.

Rock and Metal​

Rumia’s rock and metal choices are a predictable bore. Sonata Arctica and Avantasia deliver the same formulaic power metal that’s been done to death, while bands like Equilibrium and Turisas add nothing new, sticking to tired folk-metal clichés. The token punk and gothic entries like Bad Religion and HIM are shallow attempts to appear edgy, but ultimately fail to make any real impact.

Alternative and Experimental Sounds​

The so-called “alternative” and “experimental” selections are nothing more than a pretentious jumble. Björk’s offbeat style feels out of place and forced, and Diablo Swing Orchestra’s attempts at blending genres come off as gimmicky rather than innovative. Acts like Monty Python and Miracle of Sound add a forced quirkiness that only serves to highlight Rumia’s desperation to appear different.

Electronic and Industrial​

Rumia’s foray into electronic and industrial music is just as uninspired. Eisenfunk and FGFC820 bring repetitive beats and uninspired synth lines that do nothing but blend into the background. Lindsey Stirling’s violin-centric compositions are more of the same—a mishmash of classical and electronic that ends up pleasing neither camp.

Storytelling and Theatricality​

The narrative-driven songs by The Decemberists and Patty Gurdy, which Rumia seems to favor, are overwrought and pretentious. The supposed “storytelling” and “theatrical” elements feel more like an amateur dramatics club than any serious musical endeavor. The operatic rock of Therion and the steampunk schtick of Abney Park come across as tired gimmicks rather than genuine creativity.

Multilingual and International Appeal​

Rumia’s attempt at showcasing multilingual and international songs is just a superficial grab at diversity. Featuring songs in various languages is a transparent attempt to appear inclusive, but it ultimately lacks depth and sincerity. It’s more about ticking boxes than any real engagement with different cultures.

Nostalgia and Retro Influences​

Rumia’s nostalgic selections, featuring bands like Men Without Hats and Big Bad Voodoo Daddy, feel like a lazy attempt to cash in on retro trends. These songs add nothing of value and serve only to pad out a playlist already bursting with mediocrity. It’s a trip down memory lane that no one asked for and no one needs.

Conclusion​

In conclusion, Rumia’s musical style is an incoherent mishmash that fails to carve out a distinct identity. Their desperate attempt to cover every genre and influence results in a playlist that’s as inconsistent as it is uninspired. Far from being a rich tapestry, it’s a tangled mess that highlights a lack of direction and originality.
 
Top Bottom