MiraShadowMan
Well-known member
Noisex - Escape From Paradise
Could someone remind me why roster nations were included in WLSC in the first place? Makes no sense to have a WL contest with more than half of participants being non-WL nations.
It makes perfect sense to me, otherwise WLSC would be at around 8-10 participants at best, which is less fun.Could someone remind me why roster nations were included in WLSC in the first place? Makes no sense to have a WL contest with more than half of participants being non-WL nations.
Oh right thought so... maybe the contest doesn't need to be kept alive in this format, potentially another one could be more fitting with fewer participants, such as a league contest. Anyway allowing NSC nations participate really makes me not want to return to WLSC.There is no rule against it, and at one point they became vital to the survival of WLSC. For a significant time the participant numbers were less than 10 and even got as low as 5 (iirc) at one point - that was with main roster nations taking part.
That's too much effort honestly, the comfort level is too high in this community.It makes perfect sense to me, otherwise WLSC would be at around 8-10 participants at best, which is less fun.
Btw, if you want to seriously discuss this, I suggest you do so in a separate dedicated thread
As one of the main roster nations that does regularly participate here, I savour my time with the WL community as a means to help us connect and be closer during a period of time when, let's face it, there isn't a massive social interaction amongst the NSC nations out with the main contest threads. The WLSC LLs in particular are a delight, and I would feel terrible if the WL nations felt short-changed in any way with my nation taking part.
I understand your viewpoint - it's a song contest for the Waiting List members - but I don't see any harm in it being more open for participants to ensure a more vibrant and social community spirit.
Could someone remind me why roster nations were included in WLSC in the first place? Makes no sense to have a WL contest with more than half of participants being non-WL nations.
Yeah, exactly!As one of the main roster nations that does regularly participate here, I savour my time with the WL community as a means to help us connect and be closer during a period of time when, let's face it, there isn't a massive social interaction amongst the NSC nations out with the main contest threads. The WLSC LLs in particular are a delight, and I would feel terrible if the WL nations felt short-changed in any way with my nation taking part.
I understand your viewpoint - it's a song contest for the Waiting List members - but I don't see any harm in it being more open for participants to ensure a more vibrant and social community spirit. I wouldn't be against the prospect of the highest finishing WL nation getting the automatic first refusal on the hosting of the following edition for example. But it's a matter for WL nations themselves to decide on - I'm just grateful to be included and don't mean any discomfort or annoyance.