ESC United Mod Team
Super Moderator
- Joined
- February 10, 2021
- Posts
- 214
Apart from last year, it’s always been a slow build up and I personally dislike it as a fan, if they’re gonna wait til late in the pre-season to announce then more updates should be provided in my view
I think 2023 is an example of fans getting so carried away though and to me generally a slower build up is for the better.No i agree, it always feels so counter productive to me. The dead silence just allows rumours to build and fans to get certain expectations and form their own narrative. Then we're left disappointed when the actual entry doesn't fit that. Rina Sawayama and Mae Muller are the most extreme example of that but it's the case nearly every year.
Definitely. It’s even more gutting that Rina just didn’t respond in time too! She would have said yes supposedly… and after the last two years of Mae and Olly both needing therapy after the contest, I don’t think many labels would put their acts forward for fear of following the same trajectory.No i agree, it always feels so counter productive to me. The dead silence just allows rumours to build and fans to get certain expectations and form their own narrative. Then we're left disappointed when the actual entry doesn't fit that. Rina Sawayama and Mae Muller are the most extreme example of that but it's the case nearly every year.
Equally, the BBC should take some responsibility for letting things get out of control in 2023 due to minimal news (as we’ve had this year so far). Eurovision in the UK has such a diehard following and is genuinely adored by millions of us, bringing in the highest TV audiences of the year, so they could at the very least be more transparent with the steps they take to select an act and provide fairly regular updates, or perhaps even a timeline.I think 2023 is an example of fans getting so carried away though and to me generally a slower build up is for the better.
We’re invested most of the year as fans but I always look at the general viewer who only really cares 1) when the song/act is released (and possibly not even then) and 2) the night of the final (when they’ve most likely heard the song for the first time).
What goes on before that matters not to them - and that’s not a bad way to look at it really.
I don’t think the BBC should cater its hype machine/press to cater to the obsessive fans. In a way I think last year’s early announcement backfired long term for Olly and expectations.
If fans speculate to high heaven before the official announcement, so be it. That’s fans for you.
I don’t think they need to take any responsibility at all for fans speculating wildly online. Fans will speculate regardless and if they get it wrong, that’s the fans fault - not the BBC’s.Definitely. It’s even more gutting that Rina just didn’t respond in time too! She would have said yes supposedly… and after the last two years of Mae and Olly both needing therapy after the contest, I don’t think many labels would put their acts forward for fear of following the same trajectory.
Equally, the BBC should take some responsibility for letting things get out of control in 2023 due to minimal news (as we’ve had this year so far). Eurovision in the UK has such a diehard following and is genuinely adored by millions of us, bringing in the highest TV audiences of the year, so they could at the very least be more transparent with the steps they take to select an act and provide fairly regular updates, or perhaps even a timeline.
They broadcast and “look after” Eurovision in the UK - they have a major responsibility to ensure that their artists are looked after - 2023’s initial Mae backlash was because everyone was convinced it was Rina (who was the BBC’s first choice, ironically) but she didn’t respond in time. They had weeks before they announced Mae and there was plenty of opportunity to quash the tsunami of online speculation which then turned rather nasty towards Mae in the end.I don’t think they need to take any responsibility at all for fans speculating wildly online. Fans will speculate regardless and if they get it wrong, that’s the fans fault - not the BBC’s.
It’s not as if that speculation made it into the mainstream press who then ‘confirmed’ Rina was happening.
If that had happened and if the BBC hadn’t acted in response to that, yes that would be wrong, but to respond for fans ‘confirming’ something among themselves? No. That’s not what they’re there for.
There’s a dedicated loyal following, yeah. But that doesn’t mean the BBC should bow down to them.
Again I’m probably taking a very different view to many here…
‘Everyone’ being fans online - it’s really not that many people in the grand scheme of 10 million watching in May.They broadcast and “look after” Eurovision in the UK - they have a major responsibility to ensure that their artists are looked after - 2023’s initial Mae backlash was because everyone was convinced it was Rina (who was the BBC’s first choice, ironically) but she didn’t respond in time. They had weeks before they announced Mae and there was plenty of opportunity to quash the tsunami of online speculation which then turned rather nasty towards Mae in the end.
Broadcasters cannot evade the ethical responsibilities they have
I just had an imaginary fish and chip supper with Jane McDonald and she told me she had a big announcement to share on X (formally known as Twitter) soon. She then right before my eyes burst into a magnificent rendition of Conchita Wurst's Rise Like A Phoenix. Something must be brewing. Is this the year?
Watch on TikTok
Streets are saying we have a girlband represent us this year now….
The Spice Girls are in their own leagueGirls Aloud, please.
I need Nadine Coyle to meet Melody.
![]()
They lost me when they left Heidi behindI want Sugababes. I'm only accepting Sugababes.
![]()
They lost me when they left Heidi behind![]()
I’m really not sure we’re in a worse place than 2015 - the year of Electro Velvet. That is quite something to be back in those dark days - and we’re definitely not there…I literally have no hope for this year. It almost feels like we’re in a worse place than 10 years ago because now some ‘effort’ and an established act has entered and failed, we have even more of a mountain to climb. Just watching the national finals last night (Spain, Belgium, Slovenia) made me realise that some of the less impressive act still put a lot more creativity and effort into their performances than most of our last five entries (bar Sam).
They lost me when they left Heidi behind![]()