ESC United Mod Team
Super Moderator
- Joined
- February 10, 2021
- Posts
- 214
Last edited by a moderator:
Ukraine UKRAINE 2024 - Alyona Alyona & Jerry Heil - Teresa & Maria
- Thread starter ESC United Mod Team
- Start date
- Watchers 55
akoz
Well-known member
I was hoping for more strong songs in this wildcard battle. 
ANKA definitely is the best here, most likely I'll vote for here. I also like STASYA song - first minute is really great, then song kinda losing it, but overall really good attempt. And I'd not mind to see Teslenko and Karyotype in final just for diversity - songs like Lights go up could actually grow with live performances (but only with right staging) and I don't think we'd have such cute and lovely songs as Sadness from another artists in the final lineup.
Others are pretty basic and meh.
ANKA definitely is the best here, most likely I'll vote for here. I also like STASYA song - first minute is really great, then song kinda losing it, but overall really good attempt. And I'd not mind to see Teslenko and Karyotype in final just for diversity - songs like Lights go up could actually grow with live performances (but only with right staging) and I don't think we'd have such cute and lovely songs as Sadness from another artists in the final lineup.
Others are pretty basic and meh.
If somehow KRYLATA with that cringe language-change out of nowhere or SWOIIA with that lalala song win 11th place in the final over ANKA, I think we'd be doomed for another wild winner in the final this year with such fandom.
That wildcard line up is quite alright tbh, not much to complain about at all - although I will say most don't leave a massively positive impression, just ok. KRYLATA - 'Queen' is a quality bop and by far my personal fave in that list. I can totally get behind that. Of the other 2 faves (as Aleks said them to be) neither are my cup of tea. Ankas song I feel like has been done to death, I don't necessarily mean from Ukraine in ESC, I've heard this song from different Ukrainian artists 9597949 times now and i'm completely over it. SWOIIA is just ok imo, nothing more. Hopefully my fave wins the wildcard vote. 
Not sure I have ever heard phonk from Ukrainian artists
Just underground electro scene. As for ethno, I have never seen anyone with LED sopilka. Nor have I seen a woman playing this instrument.
Last edited:
PollyWantsACracker
Veteran
- Joined
- April 10, 2021
- Posts
- 3,266
Anka and Carpetman have the best final products in respect of songs.
Carpetman's song is though a bit more interesting than Anka's, which is "expected" from Ukraine.
Krylata's song, IDK, it's also well produced, but I'm tired of queens of all sorts, from queens of the kings to the queens of khans, Mata Haris, she-wolves, MF girls who run the world, and all that turd. I'm saying that as a hard core feminist.
"Only" worry here are the vocals. They are heavily produced in these studio recordings. It's hard to imagine how they would actually sound live.
The rest is so so, to quote Černobil: "Not bad, not good".
Little Angels stands out though, but maybe in a more disturbing way. The topic is absolutely great, but the way it's presented is eerie and somehow emotionally detached. Maybe it's not even tasty. Anyway, confuses a lot, so - no.
Carpetman's song is though a bit more interesting than Anka's, which is "expected" from Ukraine.
Krylata's song, IDK, it's also well produced, but I'm tired of queens of all sorts, from queens of the kings to the queens of khans, Mata Haris, she-wolves, MF girls who run the world, and all that turd. I'm saying that as a hard core feminist.
"Only" worry here are the vocals. They are heavily produced in these studio recordings. It's hard to imagine how they would actually sound live.
The rest is so so, to quote Černobil: "Not bad, not good".
Little Angels stands out though, but maybe in a more disturbing way. The topic is absolutely great, but the way it's presented is eerie and somehow emotionally detached. Maybe it's not even tasty. Anyway, confuses a lot, so - no.
Last edited:
PollyWantsACracker
Veteran
- Joined
- April 10, 2021
- Posts
- 3,266
Sorry, double post.
Melovin - "Last time, like everyone else, I did not listen to the main thing - not to think of the competition as the Olympic Games. Other Europeans have a different attitude to this competition than we do. At the time when our performers come there, they feel in a constant wild tension due to pressure from the press or people in the comments. What's going on with other Europeans at this moment? Joy, everyone is vibing, just chillin' and high on music. They treat the contest as an opportunity to meet, collaborate and please their country with a great performance. That's what I realized, and that's the most important thing in this competition". "Dreamer is unlike any other song that I've ever written".
Tsyferblat - the song is about refugees. "Eurovision is something like a guilty pleasure to me".
NAHABA - "Andrii is currently serving, and due to the fact that this song was written specifically for Eurovision, there were certain difficulties. We thought about how to preserve this connection between our contrasting personalities in different parts of the song. The last months of our lives were full of painful events, the lives of both changed in one moment. We lived together for almost five years in a relationship, but from the moment Andriy joined the ranks of the Armed Forces, everything began to gradually and irrevocably collapse. The song GLASS is a complete and sincere reflection of all these painful and complex processes and experiences."
Ingret - "My song is a manifestation of those thoughts, feelings and experiences that I have felt in recent years until now. A few months earlier, the idea of taking part in Eurovision was born and I thought about what song to create, my soul said only one thing: "Ingret, write with your heart." And my heart is now shared with many women of our country, and not only. My husband and father are military personnel. So the song and the lyrics will speak for themselves, and my voice will be an imprint of what I feel inside".
YAGODY - "the song will surpise you, because it differs from our discography". It's inspired by ancient folklore.
Jerry Heil & alyona alyona - "We chose this particular track because it's filled with meaning and carries a great message to the world. The song is different from what we've done before, because our previous songs were more about ethno, as well as war and inner feelings. This song brings us more together as two women and is very full of the Girl power theme. Simple truths that ordinary people can reach unreal heights".
Tsyferblat - the song is about refugees. "Eurovision is something like a guilty pleasure to me".
NAHABA - "Andrii is currently serving, and due to the fact that this song was written specifically for Eurovision, there were certain difficulties. We thought about how to preserve this connection between our contrasting personalities in different parts of the song. The last months of our lives were full of painful events, the lives of both changed in one moment. We lived together for almost five years in a relationship, but from the moment Andriy joined the ranks of the Armed Forces, everything began to gradually and irrevocably collapse. The song GLASS is a complete and sincere reflection of all these painful and complex processes and experiences."
Ingret - "My song is a manifestation of those thoughts, feelings and experiences that I have felt in recent years until now. A few months earlier, the idea of taking part in Eurovision was born and I thought about what song to create, my soul said only one thing: "Ingret, write with your heart." And my heart is now shared with many women of our country, and not only. My husband and father are military personnel. So the song and the lyrics will speak for themselves, and my voice will be an imprint of what I feel inside".
YAGODY - "the song will surpise you, because it differs from our discography". It's inspired by ancient folklore.
Jerry Heil & alyona alyona - "We chose this particular track because it's filled with meaning and carries a great message to the world. The song is different from what we've done before, because our previous songs were more about ethno, as well as war and inner feelings. This song brings us more together as two women and is very full of the Girl power theme. Simple truths that ordinary people can reach unreal heights".
rasmuslights
Veteran
- Joined
- November 15, 2020
- Posts
- 2,542
Melovin - "Last time, like everyone else, I did not listen to the main thing - not to think of the competition as the Olympic Games. Other Europeans have a different attitude to this competition than we do. At the time when our performers come there, they feel in a constant wild tension due to pressure from the press or people in the comments. What's going on with other Europeans at this moment? Joy, everyone is vibing, just chillin' and high on music. They treat the contest as an opportunity to meet, collaborate and please their country with a great performance. That's what I realized, and that's the most important thing in this competition". "Dreamer is unlike any other song that I've ever written".
Tsyferblat - the song is about refugees. "Eurovision is something like a guilty pleasure to me".
NAHABA - "Andrii is currently serving, and due to the fact that this song was written specifically for Eurovision, there were certain difficulties. We thought about how to preserve this connection between our contrasting personalities in different parts of the song. The last months of our lives were full of painful events, the lives of both changed in one moment. We lived together for almost five years in a relationship, but from the moment Andriy joined the ranks of the Armed Forces, everything began to gradually and irrevocably collapse. The song GLASS is a complete and sincere reflection of all these painful and complex processes and experiences."
Ingret - "My song is a manifestation of those thoughts, feelings and experiences that I have felt in recent years until now. A few months earlier, the idea of taking part in Eurovision was born and I thought about what song to create, my soul said only one thing: "Ingret, write with your heart." And my heart is now shared with many women of our country, and not only. My husband and father are military personnel. So the song and the lyrics will speak for themselves, and my voice will be an imprint of what I feel inside".
YAGODY - "the song will surpise you, because it differs from our discography". It's inspired by ancient folklore.
Jerry Heil & alyona alyona - "We chose this particular track because it's filled with meaning and carries a great message to the world. The song is different from what we've done before, because our previous songs were more about ethno, as well as war and inner feelings. This song brings us more together as two women and is very full of the Girl power theme. Simple truths that ordinary people can reach unreal heights".
Go Ingret and Jerry/Alyona
The official results after almost full 1st day
49500 people have voted in the Diia state app. 1 vote per 1 passport/ID-card.
ANKA - 22.93%
KRYLATA - 13.54%
STASYA - 11.6%
PARFENIUK - 11.18%
SHÉPA - 9.88%
Carpetman - 9.1%
SWOIIA - 8.33%
KARYOTYPE - 7.64%
TESLENKO - 5.81%
The voting will stop on December 21.
If things stay like this, we will get 2 sensations. The Voice finalist (Stasya) and influencer whose songs gained 35+ million views on YT this year (Parfeniuk), both won't qualify for Vidbir final
A poll by 24 TV channel (2100 votes):
ANKA - 26%
KRYLATA - 20%
STASYA - 12%
PARFENIUK - 12%
SWOIIA - 9%
Carpetman - 8%
TESLENKO - 6%
KARYOTYPE - 4%
SHÉPA - 3%
KRYLATA received a boost because the poll was re-posted by our ESC community. SHÉPA scored more in official results because Suspilne posted the recap of snippets (instead of full songs) in the app, and she benefits the most from this. Other than that the results are very similar.
49500 people have voted in the Diia state app. 1 vote per 1 passport/ID-card.
ANKA - 22.93%
KRYLATA - 13.54%
STASYA - 11.6%
PARFENIUK - 11.18%
SHÉPA - 9.88%
Carpetman - 9.1%
SWOIIA - 8.33%
KARYOTYPE - 7.64%
TESLENKO - 5.81%
The voting will stop on December 21.
If things stay like this, we will get 2 sensations. The Voice finalist (Stasya) and influencer whose songs gained 35+ million views on YT this year (Parfeniuk), both won't qualify for Vidbir final
A poll by 24 TV channel (2100 votes):
ANKA - 26%
KRYLATA - 20%
STASYA - 12%
PARFENIUK - 12%
SWOIIA - 9%
Carpetman - 8%
TESLENKO - 6%
KARYOTYPE - 4%
SHÉPA - 3%
KRYLATA received a boost because the poll was re-posted by our ESC community. SHÉPA scored more in official results because Suspilne posted the recap of snippets (instead of full songs) in the app, and she benefits the most from this. Other than that the results are very similar.
Last edited:
PollyWantsACracker
Veteran
- Joined
- April 10, 2021
- Posts
- 3,266
The official results after almost full 1st day
49500 people have voted in the Diia state app. 1 vote per 1 passport ID.
ANKA - 22.93%
KRYLATA - 13.54%
STASYA - 11.6%
PARFENIUK - 11.18%
SHÉPA - 9.88%
Carpetman - 9.1%
SWOIIA - 8.33%
KARYOTYPE - 7.64%
TESLENKO - 5.81%
The voting will stop on December 21.
If things stay like this, we will get 2 sensations. The Voice finalist (Stasya) and influencer with 35+ million views on YT this year (Parfeniuk), both won't qualify for Vidbir final
A poll by 24 TV channel (2100 votes):
ANKA - 26%
KRYLATA - 20%
STASYA - 12%
PARFENIUK - 12%
SWOIIA - 9%
Carpetman - 8%
TESLENKO - 6%
KARYOTYPE - 4%
SHÉPA - 3%
KRYLATA received a boost because the poll was re-posted by our ESC community. SHÉPA scored more in official results because Suspilne posted the recap of snippets (instead of full songs) in the app, and she benefits the most from this. Other than that the results are very similar.
A bit sad for Carpetman
Ravlyk
Active member
- Joined
- May 11, 2022
- Posts
- 20
Quite a good list we have here. Almost all of them are at least ok. Hope that means we are going to have interesting final.
ANKA is really good. Not my cup of tea musically, but this song can do well.
Carpetman has good song too. Strong, powerful vocals could elevate it a lot live. But I doubt he has this strength.
STASYA annoyed me a bit on the first listening. But as I gave her song a few more goes I ended up liking it. With a good revamp it could be my fave. I'd love to see her in the finals. But I don't believe I will.
ANKA is really good. Not my cup of tea musically, but this song can do well.
Carpetman has good song too. Strong, powerful vocals could elevate it a lot live. But I doubt he has this strength.
STASYA annoyed me a bit on the first listening. But as I gave her song a few more goes I ended up liking it. With a good revamp it could be my fave. I'd love to see her in the finals. But I don't believe I will.
Last edited:
Charly
Well-known member
I had a listen to the Wildcard entries and I must say the quality is great and these are only wildcard.
I have really high expectations for Vidbir to be jamp packed with gems.
I'm leaning towards either;
Anka - Palala or Stasya - Rika.
Carpetman would also be a nice wildcard choice.
I'm impressed Ukraine
I have really high expectations for Vidbir to be jamp packed with gems.
I'm leaning towards either;
Anka - Palala or Stasya - Rika.
Carpetman would also be a nice wildcard choice.
I'm impressed Ukraine
njdevils94
Veteran
- Joined
- June 16, 2018
- Posts
- 6,454
Looks like Anka has won the wildcard spot by quite a bit. Congrats to her making Vidbir 2024.
Yep. The voting ends at 10:00, but from the results it is clear.
Almost 300 000 people have voted.
ps. A couple of days ago Diia posted this poll in "Messages" so people started getting notifications and vote. Right at the same time KRYLATA bombed her chances completely by promising to donate to our army for every 1000 votes. Hon, you don't donate in exchange for your personal profit, wtf. Starting from there her votes began to shrink. Parfeniuk announced on Tiktok that his gf is pregnant and super popular influencer appeared in his video. Olya Polyakova supported his Vidbir entry in her socials so this added votes as well.
ps 2. ANKA lost The Voice duels but she beat the Voice finalist on Vidbir
Will she stay in the bottom in the final or pull off Go_A trick and jump from last to #1? It's nearly impossible to beat YAKTAK or Jerry Heil tho. She should work on her song as well because it's too short.
Almost 300 000 people have voted.
ps. A couple of days ago Diia posted this poll in "Messages" so people started getting notifications and vote. Right at the same time KRYLATA bombed her chances completely by promising to donate to our army for every 1000 votes. Hon, you don't donate in exchange for your personal profit, wtf. Starting from there her votes began to shrink. Parfeniuk announced on Tiktok that his gf is pregnant and super popular influencer appeared in his video. Olya Polyakova supported his Vidbir entry in her socials so this added votes as well.
ps 2. ANKA lost The Voice duels but she beat the Voice finalist on Vidbir
Will she stay in the bottom in the final or pull off Go_A trick and jump from last to #1?
It's nearly impossible to beat YAKTAK or Jerry Heil tho. She should work on her song as well because it's too short.
Last edited:
Fierro
Well-known member
I have feeling ANKA will remain the best song of the final. That doesn't mean she'll win though.