THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - MONTENEGRO

[Mozz]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

There are fun and moving entries: Norway, Cyprus, Greece, etc.

I've seen enough now.
I just let other people discuss with you. I feel there is nothing new to be expected in discussions with certain folks.

 

[EurovisionSmile]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

I really don't like this song. It's the worst one in the competition, in my opinion of course, I'm not an expert, I can only talk about what I like or not. I really don't understand why people keep arguing about personal taste. Anyway, 0 points.

 

[94ayd]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

Cinque punti per !

 

[Franco]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

Oh, it's a humour competition???? Silly me, I thought it was a song contest

It's a song contest, but people that go all serious about this song pretending to judge this entry using the same parameters they would use for "Suus" just lack grasp on what's been showed them. It's like giving 0 points to Cyprus because "La la la love" is not a good ballad.

 

[Arv]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

I wish I could give less than 0 points, but I can't... Sorry all you SM-lovers!

 

[Dessi]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

3 points. Catchy and hilarious but not enough to get the highest marks.

 

[Matt]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

There are fun and moving entries: Norway, Cyprus, Greece, etc.

I'm glad that you agree that Norway is a joke entry as well. The difference is though that San Marino was going for it while Norway is an unintentional joke entry. But it's a good laugh I must say.

 

[doctormalisimo]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

Simple: Bulgaria has a serious entry even if it's garbage. San Marino doesn't.

Most people would prefer a joke entry to a 'serious but garbage' entry any day

 

[Jim]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

1 point for San Marino because participate this year, for their try and because I like them, plus that in 2008 they gave to Greece 12 points and last year with their second participation they gave 8 points! Anyway good luck to San Marino!

 

[CPV4931]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

4 points...

 

[StellaStai]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

A big fat 0 from me !!!

 

[dezbee2008]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

3 for being average + 2 for epicness. It's a 5 from me.

 

[Scooby]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ Zerouuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

 

[QwaarJet]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

Most people would prefer a joke entry to a 'serious but garbage' entry any day

Give me serious but garbage any day.

 

[Peiku]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

I really don't like this song. It's the worst one in the competition, in my opinion of course, I'm not an expert, I can only talk about what I like or not. I really don't understand why people keep arguing about personal taste. Anyway, 0 points.

The thing is: it's not about taste. It's more about understanding what has been presented to you. If you're a juror in a pets talent show and a cat comes in and does 3 flic-flacs followed by 50 one arm push-ups and at the end puts a big smile on and says "thank you", you can't give it 0 points beacause you just don't like black cats. Or if you do, then don't be surprised if people call you names.

 

[busybee]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

It's a song contest, but people that go all serious about this song pretending to judge this entry using the same parameters they would use for "Suus" just lack grasp on what's been showed them. It's like giving 0 points to Cyprus because "La la la love" is not a good ballad.

I understand what you're saying but I really can't find anything funny in the San Marinese song so that I can judge it as a joke entry. What's so funny about facebook/internet/cyber etc? Her performance wasn't funny either. I could understand why Ukraine 2007, for example, was considered funny..it had made me laugh. But this song or Valentina (a 37yo woman singing about facebook) doesn't make me laugh. I just listen to it or watch the performance and go :? This for me means the song is bad. Not funny, not clever, not original. Just bad.

 

[Rose82]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

For me this song is funny, makes me smile, and is in my head all day...
5 points!

 

[Trece]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

For me this song is funny, makes me smile, and is in my head all day...
5 points!

I am sorry for you! Even Euphoria of my day is just a few hours. joke

 

[Rose82]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

I understand what you're saying but I really can't find anything funny in the San Marinese song so that I can judge it as a joke entry. What's so funny about facebook/internet/cyber etc? Her performance wasn't funny either. I could understand why Ukraine 2007, for example, was considered funny..it had made me laugh. But this song or Valentina (a 37yo woman singing about facebook) doesn't make me laugh. I just listen to it or watch the performance and go :? This for me means the song is bad. Not funny, not clever, not original. Just bad.

It's your opinion, so for you it's not funny. Don't judge others for their opinion...

 

[Rose82]

Re: THE 2012 'EXPERT' PANEL - SAN MARINO

I am sorry for you! Even Euphoria of my day is just a few hours. joke

Ok, not all day