Contact us

TÜRKIYE - Turkey 2010 - maNga - We Could be the Same

how do you rate the entry?


  • Total voters
    228

Sim

Well-known member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
19,917
Location
Evergem, Belgium
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Borderline said:
THIS SONG IS PLAGIARISM. IT IS A COPY OF RUSLANA'S SONG "KISH KISH kiSH"

[youtube:23po2jmc]8JHyL2dLzik[/youtube:23po2jmc]


I don't think so:)
 

Borderline

Well-known member
Joined
February 27, 2010
Posts
601
Location
UK
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

simmeke said:
Borderline said:
THIS SONG IS PLAGIARISM. IT IS A COPY OF RUSLANA'S SONG "KISH KISH kiSH"

[youtube:vi8msuso]8JHyL2dLzik[/youtube:vi8msuso]


I don't think so:)


Listen carefully. The verse part is almost identical!
 

Sim

Well-known member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
19,917
Location
Evergem, Belgium
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

yeah oke, maybe, but if EBU approves the song, it will no problem;)
 

DoctorX

Well-known member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
1,105
Location
Berlin
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Borderline said:
THIS SONG IS PLAGIARISM. IT IS A COPY OF RUSLANA'S SONG "KISH KISH kiSH"

[youtube:1rhb9j1h]8JHyL2dLzik[/youtube:1rhb9j1h]


Oh! C'mon :D The only similarity is both songs are made from 7 notes :lol:
 

Pretty In Pink

Active member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
369
Location
Between angels and insects
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Borderline said:
THIS SONG IS PLAGIARISM. IT IS A COPY OF RUSLANA'S SONG "KISH KISH kiSH"

[youtube:2dfoe267]8JHyL2dLzik[/youtube:2dfoe267]

So ,you have proof that all the songs are plagiarized :)
It's funny how you want to "throw" dirt on other songs but you avoided the talk about romanian song ,i do remember the slightly similarity with Anouk's song.
 

Muireanne

Active member
Joined
December 1, 2009
Posts
332
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

From far... you could call it similar... but only a few notes.

What Anouk song are you referring to that could be copied by Romania?
 

AlekS

Veteran
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
26,868
Location
Ukraine
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Not similar at all, imo. It's not Ruslana btw.
 

Muireanne

Active member
Joined
December 1, 2009
Posts
332
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Ah I see "Girl" from Dutch singer Anouk... wel except for the 3 first words (and the way the first 2 were sung)... no further similarity between Anouk's song and Romania 2010 if you ask me.

Off course... the first impression stays... so many Dutch and Belgian fans might vote for those 2 words (yah right!)
 

Guest

Guest
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

DELETED - refer to the forum rules

Please avoid excessive bad language, personal attacks and racist or obscene behavior. Failure to stick to these simple rules may ultimately lead to the banning of your account or IP address from the forum. Moderators & Admins reserve the right to ban offenders from the board, temporarily or permanently, without warning. Any disciplinary action will NOT be discussed on the board or in chat.
 

fokmey

Active member
Joined
March 16, 2010
Posts
116
Location
Istanbul, Turkey
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Gosh! Are you serious? Not similar at all!


DELETED - refer to the forum rules

Please avoid excessive bad language, personal attacks and racist or obscene behavior. Failure to stick to these simple rules may ultimately lead to the banning of your account or IP address from the forum. Moderators & Admins reserve the right to ban offenders from the board, temporarily or permanently, without warning. Any disciplinary action will NOT be discussed on the board or in chat.
 

Lidija

Active member
Joined
January 11, 2010
Posts
252
Location
LJ
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

The only thing that is similar is actually "Kish Kish Kish" with any other Ruslana song. If you know one, you know them all. :lol:
 

Borderline

Well-known member
Joined
February 27, 2010
Posts
601
Location
UK
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Lidija said:
The only thing that is similar is actually "Kish Kish Kish" with any other Ruslana song. If you know one, you know them all. :lol:

:lol:

That's not Ruslana (winner of the Eurovision Song Contest 2004). That's RusLana, a Russian singer. ;)
 

Lidija

Active member
Joined
January 11, 2010
Posts
252
Location
LJ
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Maybe you should tell the one who has uploaded the clip, as he/she thinks it's Ruslana from Ukraine. I didn't even listen to it, as Ruslana... I don't like her stuff. ;)
 

Borderline

Well-known member
Joined
February 27, 2010
Posts
601
Location
UK
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Lidija said:
Maybe you should tell the one who has uploaded the clip, as he/she thinks it's Ruslana from Ukraine. I didn't even listen to it, as Ruslana... I don't like her stuff. ;)

:shock: So, you're saying that you posted a message in which you stated that there aren't any similarities between the Turkish entry and that Russian song without even listening to it.
thumbdown.gif
 

darrenmania

Active member
Joined
March 15, 2010
Posts
126
Location
Beautiful ISTANBUL
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Borderline said:
Lidija said:
Maybe you should tell the one who has uploaded the clip, as he/she thinks it's Ruslana from Ukraine. I didn't even listen to it, as Ruslana... I don't like her stuff. ;)

:shock: So, you're saying that you posted a message in which you stated that there aren't any similarities between the Turkish entry and that Russian song without even listening to it.
thumbdown.gif
Do you really think that Manga would steal Ruslana's melody?

I am quite sure that Manga did not even hear Ruslana's name :lol:
 

Borderline

Well-known member
Joined
February 27, 2010
Posts
601
Location
UK
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

darrenmania said:
Borderline said:
Lidija said:
Maybe you should tell the one who has uploaded the clip, as he/she thinks it's Ruslana from Ukraine. I didn't even listen to it, as Ruslana... I don't like her stuff. ;)

:shock: So, you're saying that you posted a message in which you stated that there aren't any similarities between the Turkish entry and that Russian song without even listening to it.
thumbdown.gif
Do you really think that Manga would steal Ruslana's melody?

I am quite sure that Manga did not even hear Ruslana's name :lol:

:roll:
 

Lidija

Active member
Joined
January 11, 2010
Posts
252
Location
LJ
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

Borderline said:
Lidija said:
Maybe you should tell the one who has uploaded the clip, as he/she thinks it's Ruslana from Ukraine. I didn't even listen to it, as Ruslana... I don't like her stuff. ;)

:shock: So, you're saying that you posted a message in which you stated that there aren't any similarities between the Turkish entry and that Russian song without even listening to it.
thumbdown.gif

Sure. When I see a song "advertised" as Ruslana's I don't want to listen to it. I don't like her songs, no need to listen to them. :|
 

KOP

Active member
Joined
March 21, 2010
Posts
184
Location
UK
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

This song is going down my rankings :(..i usually like turkey..but this year is just average.
 

darrenmania

Active member
Joined
March 15, 2010
Posts
126
Location
Beautiful ISTANBUL
Re: TÜRK?YE - Turkey 2010 - MaNga - We Could be the Same

KOP said:
This song is going down my rankings :(..i usually like turkey..but this year is just average.
I usually don't like Turkey's entries (despite the fact that it is my home land). But this year it is different. We finally got rid of that cheap rythm based - only chorus- songs.This time it is a modern song with a lit bit ethnic figures. It will do very well in the final for sure.
 
Top Bottom