TF100 said:This debate about Portuguese is kinda redundant as RTP wouldn't let the Portuguese representative sing 100% in English anyway, the 2005 debacle is as close as we're going to get.
mrcapri said:What does rtp have to do with the fact that voters decided to vote more for Filipa and Nuno & Fabia? In my opinion nothing! Remember last year? Flor de Lis was 7th and came out as winner of Festival da Canção.
RTP is doing quite a fantastic job this year, starting with the venue. a 10000 seater capacity arena. Never has Portugal used a large arena for such an event.
The decision of using 2 semi-finals and a final show that RTP is interested in the show and of making people vote.
mikept said:mrcapri said:What does rtp have to do with the fact that voters decided to vote more for Filipa and Nuno & Fabia? In my opinion nothing! Remember last year? Flor de Lis was 7th and came out as winner of Festival da Canção.
RTP is doing quite a fantastic job this year, starting with the venue. a 10000 seater capacity arena. Never has Portugal used a large arena for such an event.
The decision of using 2 semi-finals and a final show that RTP is interested in the show and of making people vote.
what I tried to say is that i think this is not the best way to have good musicians working for esc, in my opinian all presented songs are very poor without any possibility to win, and once again, Portugal will have1 more year increasing the bad esc reputation. If RTP want to stay in esc they must invite strong musicians working for strong pieces, this is really my view. cheers
Andalublue said:mikept said:mrcapri said:What does rtp have to do with the fact that voters decided to vote more for Filipa and Nuno & Fabia? In my opinion nothing! Remember last year? Flor de Lis was 7th and came out as winner of Festival da Canção.
RTP is doing quite a fantastic job this year, starting with the venue. a 10000 seater capacity arena. Never has Portugal used a large arena for such an event.
The decision of using 2 semi-finals and a final show that RTP is interested in the show and of making people vote.
what I tried to say is that i think this is not the best way to have good musicians working for esc, in my opinian all presented songs are very poor without any possibility to win, and once again, Portugal will have1 more year increasing the bad esc reputation. If RTP want to stay in esc they must invite strong musicians working for strong pieces, this is really my view. cheers
I kind of agree with Mikept that the quality is low this year from Portugal. I listened to all the Top 10 online songs and none have much chance. It's a shame a country with a wonderful musical culture like Portugal can't persuade one of their great singers like Sara Tavares or Mariza to write and perform at ESC. Failing that... bring back Dulce Pontes or Dina!
94ayd said:Sara Tavares finished 8th of 25... That doesn't seem too bad to me.
mikept said:94ayd said:Sara Tavares finished 8th of 25... That doesn't seem too bad to me.
right....not to bad, but ...she didn´t won also Lucia Moniz finished 6th, the best ever place of Portugal in esc with a strong music , but also she didn´t won and many others but.....Portugal never won....