I think the main reason for comparing the two, is that both songs are typical swedish acts, what the swedes like to call "effective popsongs". The songwriters has a receipe, and they stick to it, and when a song is a swedish production, noone can be mistaken. That's one of the main reasons why I hate "Stay". Tooji is a nice guy for sure. While Saade seemed like an arrogant brat, Tooji gives a very sympathetic impression. But the song is crap, it's not a norwegian production, it falls in the same category as Saade last year, Reidun Sæther from the national final this year. Carola would have murdered her great grandmother for that song. Add a windmachine and a sudden keychange before the last refrain, and you have a typical swedish esc-song.
I think the songwriter workshop-weekends where songwriters comes together to write for the national finals makes the entire competition more homogenic and less authentic for each country participating. The swedish songwriters seems to have a song or two in every final, Thomas G:Son for instance wrote Reidun Sæthers song, He co-produced Spains winning song and he's written Swedens song. I would actually say the swedish songwriters are spamming the contest with uninteresting crappy songs that sucks originality and creativity out of the competition.
Add the new voting-trend, where international jurys are voting in national finals to find the song that would most likely collect most votes from abroad, and you end up with something bland and forgettable wich represent the continent rather than a specific country.
Sitat:
I would actually say the swedish songwriters are spamming the contest with uninteresting crappy songs that sucks originality and creativity out of the competition.
-------------
Amen !!!
If you hate our songwriters so much, why did you even add Tooji as your avatar pic (afterall it IS a Swedish song)? Hypocrisy much? ("Hate those Swedish songwriters spamming our contest - however thanks for the winning entry!")
However, I do agree about the problem, but it's not our fault that you (and other countries aswell) allow foreign writers to take part in their selections. It's not out fault that EBU doesn't have any rules concerning this and it's not our fault that we're one of the world's "biggest countries" when it comes to music industry
Maybe because Tooji him self is standing 50% behind Stay and maybe because it was better than Plumbo.
HAHA 50 per cent, stop fooling yourself and look up how its done. According to the writer himself, Tooji put his "touch" on it same as Danny did on his Amazing. its more like 5 per cent Tooji and 95 per cent swedish.Maybe because Tooji him self is standing 50% behind Stay and maybe because it was better than Plumbo.
Maybe because Tooji him self is standing 50% behind Stay and maybe because it was better than Plumbo.
Plumbo would indeed had been worse
Sitat:
I would actually say the swedish songwriters are spamming the contest with uninteresting crappy songs that sucks originality and creativity out of the competition.
-------------
Amen !!!
He's just great I especially at the swedish parody..