IRELAND 2012 - Jedward - Waterline

[LakZaNokte]

it's not terrible or something but...
this sounds like typical boy band song from the90's

meh, I'll give a 5

 

[PeterLPZ]

It´s one of the better songs this year. I like it more than last years entry.

 

[Synergise]

I didn't like the song when I originally heard it... but I liked the live performance! I actually think it's a pretty good song now... not sure if I'll be voting for them again this year though!

 

[lippy98]

I love the song, John and Edward rock!!!!
skip to 10.55 to see them perform waterline

 

[Milos-BC]

Ehm.........well for me this was an expected script, as all songs in the NF were quite weak, and this was in some way "the least bad"

I don't know what to say, I totally disliked "Lipstick" last year, and I find this one quite more listenable, but it is quite bad and bland as an entry.

I am not against participating for two times in a row when the song is good (like Lena's was last year), but this is lame.

I think they fail badly this year.

As for the song, just 1 point. At least it's better than "Lipstick"

 

[Franco]

Oh my!
Too bad, because the song is ok, but their performance doesn't go far from last year's.

 

[lippy98]

The song sounds very "American pop" true, more mainstream than Lipstick, and that was the purpose I guess.
I like it!

 

[94ayd]

I can't believe they went for this. The song is way lamer and has no hook, unlike "Lipstick" and they still move the same way only with worse costumes and possibly vocals - 4.

 

[Israeliboy]

I start to miss "Lipstick" . I don't like it, sorry Ireland. Last year they were in my top10, this year not Goodluck!

 

[Sim]

Hmm this sounds more like an American pop group, don't know, maybe a final not as good as last year, but ok last year I didn't like lipstick also not in the beginning

 

[escandesc]

I was addicted to Lipstick at first listening but this one is ... I don't know. it sounds so simple but I must admit that I like the live version much more. They are pretty good at singing this song live. I do wonder which place they're gonna take. 4 points from me for the sake of Jedward and Lipstick

 

[Melicia]

They gonna win!

 

[Bart]

Ireland made the right choice. Waterline sounds more Eurovision than Lipstick, but I liked Lipstick more.

 

[Sean]

I'm surprised at their live performance, I thought they'd be shocking at this song as it doesn't really suit their voices. They've done an alright job of it though.

And it's a more polished entry than Lipstick for me, I think I might prefer it 6 points from me, as the live vocals DO need to still be improved a bit

 

[TheLuflee]

*facepalm*

 

[Arv]

Back to the 90's with Ireland and Jedward...

 

[bashers]

Hmmm for me, this is like Marmite. You either love it or hate it. Bit of a rock start to the song - they should change this imo. However...the song does have potential. hmmm 4 points!

 

[Mickey]

Bit of a rock start to the song - they should change this imo.

You don't listen to much rock, do you?

I like this more now than when I first heard it. They just about get away with it vocally, although they struggle with the big notes. Jedward could yet do well with this. I'm worried. Very worried.

 

[rajo]

For the live performance I only gave 1 point.

But now that I have listened to the studio version, I like it a lot. Well, I think this song needs some improvement for going live.

 

[stevan989]

I didn't like Jedward last year, and this year I hate Jedward yet! :? They are so uninteresting and antitallented, and song is awful for me too... One big 0!