ESC United Mod Team
Super Moderator
- Joined
- February 10, 2021
- Posts
- 214
I'm more in favour of an internal selection again for France. I think an established professional act is more likely to enter that way, personally.
I disagree. Obviously there are people not liking them but it has always been the case ("Amir sings in english", "Requiem is like Indila", "Mercy is too political and other countries won't undertand anyway", no need to explain for Bilal, "Barbara is just like Edith Piaf"). You can't just say that that they are not liked because theyre are a few comments under facebook posts from people who never watched the contest and will never, anyway.Our last two entries received a lot of undeserved criticisms from French people themselves.
Alvan & Ahez were criticized because they were from Britanny, didn't sing in French, and didn't represent the country as a whole. The sound was considered too ethnic by some people and the criticism was therefore easy from people who don't know the contest very well but still care about the name of the artist.
La Zarra was a Canadian artist, and therefore she was not legitimate to represent the country. Moreover her finger gesture and the fact she wanted to embody a French diva didn't help at all, and she received backlash.
Public opinion is what it is, but I do agree with you rasmuslights when you say we would need a big name next year, just like Amir in 2016. A lot of people forget easily that we've improved a lot our results since 2010s entries (remember 2014/2015 ??), so maybe a big name would help to create a popular craze about the event.
I was not referring to FB comments but more of a general atmosphere that is subjective.I disagree. Obviously there are people not liking them but it has always been the case ("Amir sings in english", "Requiem is like Indila", "Mercy is too political was other countries won't undertand anyway", no need to explain for Bilal, "Barbara is juste like Edith Piaf"). You can't just say that that they are not liked because theyre are a few comments under facebook posts from people who never watched the contest and will never, anyway..
But in the end, all of them except Bilal were quite well received by the french audience (except for Alma and Alvan and Ahez, I feel like people just didn't care about them at all), even La Zarra (before the polemic about the pre-party).
Our last two entries received a lot of undeserved criticisms from French people themselves.
Alvan & Ahez were criticized because they were from Britanny, didn't sing in French, and didn't represent the country as a whole. The sound was considered too ethnic by some people and the criticism was therefore easy from people who don't know the contest very well but still care about the name of the artist.
La Zarra was a Canadian artist, and therefore she was not legitimate to represent the country. Moreover her finger gesture and the fact she wanted to embody a French diva didn't help at all, and she received backlash.
Public opinion is what it is, but I do agree with you rasmuslights when you say we would need a big name next year, just like Amir in 2016. A lot of people forget easily that we've improved a lot our results since 2010s entries (remember 2014/2015 ??), so maybe a big name would help to create a popular craze about the event.
How much is ARA involved in the creative process of the entries? You can clearly see that she is a very visible HoD.
I'm guessing you are not onboard with that...
That was pretty hard to guess
I thought that too! She was also the only one that Lisandro bothered to hug after winning while robbing his entire background dancers and instead falling on the floor several times.Yes, she is really much involved in the creative process, and for a proper reason : i don't know if someone said that already, but she's not only French Eurovision and JESC HoD but also France TV's head of music and entertainment programs. Thus said, i agree with you, she's taking imo too much place, and french eurofans have a kind of love/hate relationship with her.
Fun fact : about that Lisandro thing, i saw last JESC with my mom, she thought ARA was Lissandro's mother lol
I didn't know her so I listened to the EP: it is really nice!Nour's EP "Premiers Amours" is reaaaally good, I think she would be a very good option for France