ESC United Mod Team
Super Moderator
- Joined
- February 10, 2021
- Posts
- 214
Last edited by a moderator:
The video of vesna is not accessible anymore in russia belarus.
I Wonder if the eurovision show of 2022 is accessible there ?
For real?
Isn´t it ironic that RuZZia had submitted tons of fake "peace/freedom" propaganda songs to Eurovision and here were are... finally having a song about Slavic sisterhood, unity and freedom and they censored it?
What a shitshow.
I just listened to Vesna given the excitement and the immediate impression from the wording of the lyrics and such is it's pro-Ukraine, anti-Russia. Especially with that intro and some of the lyric choices. Now I could be wrong on that, but it's my impression and it's not hate, don't come for me. I actually like it quite a lot, I haven't heard the others in the selection but it's the first song that has really crossed me as being potentially very competitive (from what I've listened to and with the caveat as the juries might brush it off). Ironically, given it's about Slavic Sisterhood and what not, the part I don't like so much is the English. Not because it's English, but because I think the lyrics in English seem slightly 'basic' and cheapen the whole package a bit. That said it definitely would be a very good choice from Czech Republic.
It clearly is pro-Ukrainian since it´s about Slavic countries ´sisterhood and path to independence and freedom.
The parts in Czech, Ukrainian and Bulgarian lift the song to another level; the Ukrainian part makes it current and strengthens the core message of the song - especially since there is a Russian member who´s strongly criticising RuZZia´s imperial war. It also makes the whole song authentic.. it balances the fact that there are English lyrics, imo - they are somehow necessary to make the whole message understood. Russian used to be the lingua franca but it´s the language of colonialism and imperialism in the Eastern sphere of Europe and thus, including English also highlights the fact that English has become the lingua franca among the younger generations of Central and Eastern European countries as well.
Are they basic in terms of language? - probably you´re right but the metaphors are quite strong (not being your doll = implicitly referring to Russain dolls [?], taking down the sister´s crown [trying to make Ukraine fall and deprive them their right to be indepentent and strong] - and they somehow had to make compromises, I think.. the English parts are quite short as well - all parts are due to making use of 4 different languages - but somehow the whole parts come all together and build a perfect song ... sometimes, I think that so many entries (as long as they are not single words) can make a Eurovision song sound very artificial but it´s not the case here... it´s a Eurovision anthem about to happen, imo.
Are these the same people, though?God remember when people were losing their mind over Elis Mraz last year? The Czech NF is so much better this year
Well good, my judgement on that part was correct. It doesn't surprise me at all then that Russia and Belarus have thrown a bitch fit over it and blocked it. It means it's doing something right. I don't have an issue with English being there at all and given your explaination it actually makes some sense. It's less about the metaphors, but for me more about the use of some words and the 'flow'. The other 3 languages fit perfectly into the song, in tone, emotion and more, which makes sense given they're Slavic languages. The English however stands out like a sore thumb and even in a couple of lines doesn't fit with the melody - I hope it makes sense, i'm terrible at explaining my views when it comes to music. It's a whole other language family for one. Other English speakers may not agree at all with me, but because I can clearly understand and hear the English it just doesn't sit right unlike the rest of the song. It's not a huge deal for me though.
The wayThey could have included some snippets from YU-languages.