Everyone is really hyped tbh, when I listened to the song for the first time I wasn't expecting that, I was not very impressed after the first listen but It's slowly growing on me...
I can never put "Violent Thing" at the level of Michael Schulte's song and performance, both were memorable for me, it's actually one of my favorite songs from 2018. But it's still way better than other German entries from the 10's, maybe I just like 2010, 2011 and 2013 more than this one. This is well-produced, but for some reason I have no interest on listening to it again, which is weird since I usually like this kind of stuff.
Most of the hype may be justified with how the year is shaping up, there are many slow songs and ballads and the different songs aren't that appealing (apart from Lithuania maybe)... I would be a little bit (very little) ok to see this as the fan favourite generic pop radiofriendly song this year if nothing very good comes (I doubt that will happen ofc). It's middle of the road for me -

is probably too harsh, a

is fair... I'm probably the wrong guy here
P. S. I'm glad to say

has my favorite Big 5 entry this year

... Never happened before with me since I avidly follow the contest