Contact us

The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - We have a winner!

r3gg13
united_states

r3gg13

Well-known member
Joined
December 23, 2010
Posts
10,259
Location
Westchester - Los Angeles
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 4 (FYR MACEDONIA)

:mk: this year sounds like a demo disc for all the possible versions of the song. Although well polished and nicely finished, it feels like a cop out when you try multiple genres in the same song. It's like they couldn't think of which version to send, so they mashed them all together. (because why not, it's Eurovision). In my opinion, mixing multiple genres rarely adds value to songs- this song is no exception.

4/10 (4 for how well finished the song is, it would have 8+, had they stuck to just 1 genre).
 
BernadetteCydonia
lithuania

BernadetteCydonia

Well-known member
Joined
May 15, 2015
Posts
4,022
Location
#makinglithuaniafamous
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 4 (FYR MACEDONIA)

Feels odd to not see any reviews for :cy: but just mine. Where were all the fellow summer pop enthusiasts?? :( (well there's MatiMati but not in this thread... plus mine got featured but trimmed yaaay xheya)
 
Sean
canada

Sean

Admin
Staff member
Joined
September 28, 2009
Posts
17,245
Location
Calgary
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 1 (SPAIN)

05. ALBANIA - Eugent Bushpepa - Mall

05-ALBANIA-850x491.png


Read the "Expert" Panel reviews and vote in the poll here!

Do #YOU agree with our views on Albania? What's your opinion? Share your review of the Albanian entry below and we'll feature the best across the main site!​
 
BernadetteCydonia
lithuania

BernadetteCydonia

Well-known member
Joined
May 15, 2015
Posts
4,022
Location
#makinglithuaniafamous
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 5 (ALBANIA)



:al:

It takes time to buildup but once the power strikes, it's impactful and fills you up with joy and happiness. Though this type of 'folk' rock barely ever qualified that much and I fear the same will happen this time for Albania, no matter the semi difficulty, I'll keep my fingers crossed for Albania to succeed anyway.

10/10
 
Sean
canada

Sean

Admin
Staff member
Joined
September 28, 2009
Posts
17,245
Location
Calgary
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 1 (SPAIN)

06. CZECH REPUBLIC - Mikolas Josef - Lie to Me

06-CZECH-REPUBLIC-850x491.png


Read the "Expert" Panel reviews and vote in the poll here!

Do #YOU agree with our views on Czech Republic? What's your opinion? Share your review of the Czech entry below and we'll feature the best across the main site!​
 
BernadetteCydonia
lithuania

BernadetteCydonia

Well-known member
Joined
May 15, 2015
Posts
4,022
Location
#makinglithuaniafamous
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 6 (CZECH REPUBLIC)

:cz:

Blonde nerdy schoolboy tries to get girls for himself that won't cheat with another by writing a "Talk Dirty" ripoff and shaming one girl he met, he liked and that indeed went for another man. And those lyrics, too. Camels, spaghetti and wood all night long. Compressing all this it comes out as a decent product to be played on the radio these days.

6.7/10
 
QwaarJet
scotland

QwaarJet

ESC Moderator
Joined
March 27, 2010
Posts
9,209
Location
Kilmacolm,Scotland
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 6 (CZECH REPUBLIC)

Czech Republic -

Very catchy, but also very slimy. Mikolas comes across as arrogant and creepy, and even in the new family friendly version, the lyrics are borderline offensive and sexist. The tune is a little too simple, but does have somewhat of an earworm quality about it.

2/10
 
BernadetteCydonia
lithuania

BernadetteCydonia

Well-known member
Joined
May 15, 2015
Posts
4,022
Location
#makinglithuaniafamous
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 7 (MALTA)

tfw I'm only one writing reviews in here (this thread) and they're not getting picked up anyway...

:mt:

For once an entry this year that's just there. It attracts some people because Christabelle's vocals or the lyrics (that are incredibly by-the-numbers imo, at least in the chorus), but for me the whole song is just there and nothing more, nothing less. Not even dubstep saves it anyhow. Though I indeed like her vocal decency and the key of the chorus, it separates itself from the bland verses.
 
Sean
canada

Sean

Admin
Staff member
Joined
September 28, 2009
Posts
17,245
Location
Calgary
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 7 (MALTA)

BernadetteCydonia said:
tfw I'm only one writing reviews in here (this thread) and they're not getting picked up anyway...
Click to expand...

I have to try and vary it a bit but at this rate you'll get your turn again very soon ;)
 
Nicfedy

Nicfedy

Well-known member
Joined
December 17, 2011
Posts
760
Location
Hove
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 7 (MALTA)

For some reason I can't vote on the page there is no option. Maybe I was too late. Anyway I would have given Czech 4 and Malta 9.
 
Kevan1994
canada

Kevan1994

Well-known member
Joined
March 19, 2018
Posts
389
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 7 (MALTA)

It's a difficult challenge to try to craft an intelligent pop song centred around mental health that. I definitely applaud the effort and some of the lyrics in the verses are actually quite powerful in telling a story (e.g. I know that I am not alone; Let all our thoughts and ghosts unfold; In the darkness I’ve found home; But what is next is still unknown). Unfortunately, the styling of the song doesn't allow the listener to fully focus on the message in a meaningful way. Also, the clichéd use of "sticks and stones" and the repeating of words in the chorus (i.e. "animals, animals", "criminals, criminals", "miracles, miracles") makes the song feel instantly cheapened. Overall, I'd give Taboo a 6/10 and have it ranked #28 in my top 43.
 
BernadetteCydonia
lithuania

BernadetteCydonia

Well-known member
Joined
May 15, 2015
Posts
4,022
Location
#makinglithuaniafamous
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 8 (CROATIA)

:hr:

"Zemer ku je" meets "Fly with Me" meets Lady Gaga meets Alicia Keys meets The Great Gatsby..? Eh? The video is well-directed I guess, and the song... soundtracks the late night passion with a remarkably strong third chorus and the pronouncing alterations between "krej-ze-ah" and "krej-zy". Decent but just perhaps not enough.

(even if most of them won't make it I hope to post a review for (almost) every day)
 
Sean
canada

Sean

Admin
Staff member
Joined
September 28, 2009
Posts
17,245
Location
Calgary
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 1 (SPAIN)

09. UNITED KINGDOM - SuRie - Storm

09-UNITED-KINGDOM-850x491.png


Read the "Expert" Panel reviews and vote in the poll here!

Do #YOU agree with our views on the United Kingdom? What's your opinion? Share your review of the British entry below and we'll feature the best across the main site!​
 
QwaarJet
scotland

QwaarJet

ESC Moderator
Joined
March 27, 2010
Posts
9,209
Location
Kilmacolm,Scotland
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 9 (UNITED KINGDOM)

A solid, anthemic pop song with a likeable, charismatic and powerful performer. I would say it's the best UK entry since 2014, but Molly was poor on the night. I think many fans will be surprised at how well this does...as long as they don't mess up the staging.
 
Sean
canada

Sean

Admin
Staff member
Joined
September 28, 2009
Posts
17,245
Location
Calgary
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 1 (SPAIN)

10. FINLAND - Saara Aalto - Monsters

10-FINLAND-850x491.png


Read the "Expert" Panel reviews and vote in the poll here!

Do #YOU agree with our views on Finland? What's your opinion? Share your review of the Finnish entry below and we'll feature the best across the main site!​
 
QwaarJet
scotland

QwaarJet

ESC Moderator
Joined
March 27, 2010
Posts
9,209
Location
Kilmacolm,Scotland
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 10 (FINLAND)

The kind of song I don't like to hear at Eurovision. A typical, tuneless radio song. It's all sizzle and no steak. I really hate the current trend of having almost non-existent choruses, and this song continues that. This feels more like a JESC song, and the staging will likely be completely over the top. Beyond the fan bubble, I don't see much support for this.
 
Himan
ukraine

Himan

Well-known member
Joined
March 16, 2018
Posts
1,997
Re: The ESC United "Expert Panel" 2018 - DAY 10 (FINLAND)

I am trying to like the song, but I just can't. Especially live at the big notes I really dislike it. Her voice doesn't fit with this kind of song. Though she probably likes this the best. The good news is that this contest hasn't have much songs like this one, so it can still qualify.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom