ESC United Mod Team
Super Moderator
- Joined
- February 10, 2021
- Posts
- 214
You hate blindly and whine about haters.I was almost gonna refrain from commenting on this at all, for ethical reasons. But i might as well say it - it's a good thing that it's not a good song, because then if they try the same thing they did last year, nobody can seriously claim the results were because of the song. I don't see any enthusiasm from Muslim-haters and psychopathic genocide supporters for this like last year, and i think that's a good sign. They realized it didn't work (to improve Israel's image in any way) and hopefully they'll stay out of the contest entirely this year. It might still make the final, might get a left side result, but it will be forgotten by everyone else. That's all i have to say.
Her voice is natural - not constructed and forced, as so many vocals are nowadays, also at Eurovision. This is the strength of the song, but melodically it's not the most impressive ballad I've ever heard. The part in French - I wondered if she or the song has any specific connection to France, but it doesn't seem like it, so that annoys me a bit (three languages in one song is too much if it isn't motivated by something particular). I'll give Israel a 5 for now. Hurricane was a slightly better song, I think.
Now I remember which song it does remind me ... Ne me quitte pas of Jacques Brel.
People on here seem to disagree but the song is not bad and is a mostly English language ballad in a year filled with native language televote bait. It will stand out and be voteable for casuals. Israel's presence + her backstory will be what everyone talks about in May. That will mobilise the same supporters from last year easily. Just like last year, I think ignoring Israel until the week of the contest is stupid.
I wonder if the imagery/symbolism they will use for the staging will be as obvious/heavyhanded as in the music video. I don't really want to comment much more on her, her backstory or discuss the themes of the video, as I think it's way too sad and macabre.