Re: Canada | WV90: "Zobo vs. The Suggestions" NF, and some catchup
Is it time to make a green room post on my WV90 entry almost four days after said entry NQed? I think it is
So, um, yes, Tomato/Tomato won my WV90 NF. I'm sure this comes as a huge surprise to you all at this point. Anyways, before a bit of a write-up on the entry, let's finally see those NF results!
In general, every one of the six songs on offer ended up being someone's favourite, which I thought was pretty cool. Nice to see the diversity paying off a little. Anyway, I mentioned before that every one of these six songs seemed like the most likely winner at some point, so I figure I may as well go through how things went down from my perspective.
Before the first set of votes came in, I was expecting this to go to
Complicated: while I knew it'd be a divisive song, it was obviously the best-known of the six, and I figured it'd have its fair share of fans. Clearly, though, the first set of votes didn't go Avril's way, with Lupus putting her dead last in his rankings.
Instead, the top score was taken by
Zodiac. Perhaps the instrumental song would take things in what I had originally thought would be a surprise win? Instrumentals do, after all, tend to win my NFs whenever I include them; the song stands out against the rest of the field; and I usually get a lot of voters from the later pots voting in my NFs. But the tides quickly changed, as you can see, with the quirky electronic piece following up its 10 with a slew of low points and never again reaching the top two in anyone's votes. Sorry about that, [MENTION=14505]Lupus[/MENTION]!
The next couple of voters then made things look like
Artificial Nocturne would take out the win. By that point, all three of the first voters had put the song in their top three; perhaps, I thought, the strong production values and cross-pot appeal would see the song take the win as a bit of a consensus pick. Some disagreement started popping up around the song over the next few sets of votes, though, and while it gained further support, it had a few too many low scores to push it back into contention.
Around here, I also thought
Complicated might still stand a chance: it was going strong apart from that first set of votes, and had gotten some unexpected points. Looking at you here, [MENTION=9441]RainyWoods[/MENTION]... I think seeing you praise Avril with high points while giving only a 3 to Leonard Cohen must be the most unexpected moment of any NF I've ever held, and I imagine it will be difficult to top. Low points to one of your beloved idols, second place to Avril Lavigne and top points to a foot-tappy folk pop song complete with "whoa-oh-oh"s... I had to check quite a few times to make sure I was reading your username correctly
Regardless, as we went on with another few sets of voters, and
Toss It All Away took the lead for the first time - it had only gotten a single 10 (and wouldn't get another for the rest of the NF), but was getting through by virtue of becoming the consensus leader that I originally thought Artificial Nocturne would be, as it wasn't in the bottom two of any single voter (and again, would keep this trend going until the end).
My focus at this mid point, though, was more on Leonard Cohen's alternative
You Want It Darker. Having initially seen the song get low points from those who I thought might support it, I figured its chances were dead and it was in for an uber-flop, but to my surprise it shot up the scoreboards with an incredibly strong run of 10-10-5-10. The momentum was there, it took first for a brief period, and a couple of my usual late-pot voters hadn't turned up; perhaps Leonard would win after all!
Those predictions were dashed with the next few voters, who pushed the song back down to a lower spot and instead raised up a new candidate:
The Lucky Ones. With nine sets of votes in, the song had climbed to the first place on the scoreboard through a solid mix of 10s, 7s and 5s, hadn't done particularly badly with any pot, and most tellingly, was the only remaining suggestion for which the player who suggested the song (@esc87fan) was yet to vote. She never did manage to make it, though - a fact which, combined with a couple of 3s from the last two voters, left the song a little short of the finish line.
Coming towards the end, my attention shifted again to Avril, who managed an almost-perfect run across the last three sets of votes... but as we reached the deadline,
Toss It All Away remained the consensus winner, and so I had my WV90 entry. What a ride!
I wish I could take the credit for being the one to discover this fun little folk number, but I actually kind of stole it: my first experience with the song was in [MENTION=5527]Charly[/MENTION]'s magnificent
NF for New Brunswick some 25 editions prior. And truth be told, this isn't even the first Canadian song I took from that NF - my internally selected WV88 entry Cold Water was also a runner-up there. Having now flopped with both of those entries, perhaps I should stay away from sourcing any more songs from that particular thread
I never quite knew what to expect in sending this song to WV - I wouldn't have been surprised with either a flop in the semi or a top-10 finish - and so when the song's journey ended with an NQ, I wasn't particularly shocked. I'd have loved to see it go further, of course, but you can't win 'em all. Regardless, thanks to those who voted for the song in the semi, and once again to everyone who made my NF for the edition so much fun to run!
And so we move on to WV91, and I've still got a few exciting things up my Canadian sleeve. Setting aside another general + suggestions NF (which I wouldn't want to put right after this one) and a second-chance NF (which I'll leave for last, if I want to do one), two options are springing to mind. The first is to hold an entirely instrumental NF, which would probably take me a little back to my Japan-Zobo roots (though still with a different feel, of course); the second is to internally select an obscure rock/metal entry with vague ties to a runner-up from an old Japanese NF of mine, in a move that I imagine would please [MENTION=15013]Ringdalen[/MENTION] and then be met with an "ugh" from virtually everyone else in WV
I'm entirely open to suggestions of songs, thoughts on the above plans or anything else, but otherwise I'll get down to thinking over the next few days. Looking forward to whatever it is!