Red or Brown Sauce?

[doctormalisimo]

Another age-old question, although I think only British and Irish people will know how big of a deal this is...
Which is better: red sauce or brown sauce?
This

or this?

 

[goktengri]

well it changes with foods, but I like to use red one on spaghetti

 

[Sean]

I love tomato sauce, but BBQ is awesome too

 

[Interrail]

This brown sauce....is it 'gravy' sauce or something else??

Edit:
Oh, 'brown' is BBQ sauce? Then I don't like it.
Ketchup is better

 

[sannerz]

America is all about its sauces. Different types of ketchup, and huge varieties of BBQ sauces, some good, some not so good (to me). But ketchup is the greatest thing that's happened to the world. My family goes through a jumbo container of ketchup per week. So, red sauce.

 

[doctormalisimo]

Btw if there is any confusion over the name: we call tomato sauce 'red sauce' and BBQ sauce 'brown sauce'. We're fun that way

 

[MyHeartIsYours]

Brown Sauce isnt BBQ sauce is it? I always thought they were different!

Anyway, I only like Tomato Ketchup... it's lovely! I only really have it with fish and chips though, for me it doesnt really go with much else. As for Brown Sauce, Id rather DIE than eat that!

 

[r3gg13]

It depends for me, if I'm eating steak I would rather have steak sauce. If I'm eating French fries, I would rather have ketchup.

 

[Interrail]

Why not french fries with mayonnaise

 

[Charly]

I hate Ketchup but I love Brown Sauce

 

[Kryptonite]

I Ketchup!

 

[Charly]

I Ketchup!

Dont make me throw Brown Brown sauce at you

 

[aletem]

Ketchup all the way!!! The only brown sauce I like is the gravy.

Why not french fries with mayonnaise

mmmmmm., with ketchup and mayonnaise and some feta cheese on top + oregano.

 

[MyHeartIsYours]

I had fries (well chips) and mayonnaise tonight, God I love it! xdrool

 

[r3gg13]

I had fries (well chips) and mayonnaise tonight, God I love it! xdrool

I tried that a while back, with just (Western) mayonnaise alone, it was too creamy for my liking. I usually use Japanese mayonnaise because it has a more tart and lighter taste, and mix it with any ketchup. When I want some spice in the mix, I add a bit of cayenne or paprika.

 

[DeepInsidePaulOscar]

I vote for red, but love both.
Red is for chip butties.
Brown is for cheese sarnies.
Red and brown are for mushrooms, but not at the same time.