Forum Skin/Layout

[Matt]

This topic is for all members to provide us with constructive feedback.


We are currently changing the forum layout so all members have the opportunity to check out the forum and let us know what they think. Some of them you may not like but that is the purpose of the experiment. We want to find 2 or 3 styles and give the users the opportunity to choose whichever they like best.

Remember that we are looking for helpful & constructive feedback. While comments such as "they all suck" or "just use the first one, don't even bother" may describe how you feel, it doesn't really help us.


Here are screenshots of skins used so far:


1 Liquid Blue

2 Red Metal

3 Take Five

4 Aqua

 

[Sim]

Of the 2 skins we have at the moment I prefer the first one.

The current one - number 2 - reminds me too much to a game forum or something like that. It's not really eurovision to me.
I prefer the first one because it's light, simple and also a bit colourful.
Maybe it can sound weird, but a blue color makes me happy while the red-brown color makes me more sad.

 

[Matt]

Simmeke:

What do you think of the new forum style?

I like it, only thing I found negative is that it's too small...

Just moving Simmeke's post over here

 

[94ayd]

Liquid Blue for me, too.

 

[Karlicious]

First

 

[Schlagerman1]

Yeah I say the first one, this red one is a bit creepy...

 

[Matt]

Okay, thanks for the input. Next one's up

 

[Schlagerman1]

This brown is nice..if it was a Survivor forum!

 

[Sean]

This one's really cool but I think I prefer the blue one

1 Liquid Blue
2 Take Five
3 Red Metal

 

[MyHeartIsYours]

Red Metal and Take Five are equally brilliant but I think that Liquid Blue is boring and similar to what we've had in the past.

 

[Jukica]

I like Liquid Blue and Take Five, but I don't like Red Metal ... and is there option for widescreen monitors? It looks pretty ... empty without widescreen :/

 

[MyHeartIsYours]

The page has gone too wide now cuz I cant read the bits at the side cuz it's too dark.

 

[goktengri]

red metal is better for me

 

[AlekS]

The page issue has been solved.
Liquid Bue is still my fave

 

[Matt]

Next one is up, this one's called Aqua

 

[Jukica]

Aqua is amazing, best one
1. Aqua
2. Liquid Blue
(I like only these 2)
3. Red Metal
4. Take Five (both are not good for widescreen :/)

 

[AlekS]

Aqua is too white... basically it was created on the base of Vbulletin's default skin.
1. Liquid Blue
2. Aqua

 

[Matt]

pretty much what aleks said. I wanted to give it a shot as it looked nice on paper....

 

[Jukica]

^ It's easy to read posts when it's not with too much colours (at least for me)

 

[94ayd]

1.
4.
3.
2.

That's my ranking of them (from best to worst).