PDA

View Full Version : Rank the Big 5 + Host entries 2018



FreeFair
14th March 2018, 18:47
12- Portugal
10- Germany
8- Spain
7- France
6- UK
5- Italy
In my opinion this is the strongest year for automatic qualifiers since 2012 & 2011. They all chose in Public national selections & the quality is much higher than it has been lately. Even the British song, which may be bland, is going to be well performed by an experienced Eurovision participant.

Realest
14th March 2018, 19:11
Portugal
Germany
Italy
France
Spain
UK

Dodiih
14th March 2018, 19:16
::12 ::it
::10 ::es
::8 ::de
::7 ::uk
::6 ::pt
::5 ::fr

DaFlo
14th March 2018, 19:19
::12 ::it
::7 ::pt
::6 ::fr
::3 ::es
::3 ::de
::1 ::uk

nunaney
14th March 2018, 19:27
::12 ::pt
::10 ::it
::8 ::fr
::7 ::de
::6 ::es
::5 ::uk

I actually like all of them except for the UK. But ::pt is magical xlove

midnightsun
14th March 2018, 19:48
1. France
2. Portugal
3. Italy
4. Germany
5. UK
6. Spain

Citelis
14th March 2018, 19:57
1. ::it
2. ::pt
3. ::es
4. ::uk
5. ::de
6. ::fr

Haven't decided yet if i like Italy or Portugal more!

94ayd
14th March 2018, 20:07
1. ::fr (overall 1st)
2. ::pt (overall 3rd)
3. ::it (11th)
4. ::uk (24th)
5. ::de (38th)
6. ::es (40th)

0scar
14th March 2018, 20:19
1. ::fr
2. ::de
3. ::it
4. ::uk
5. ::pt
6. ::es

Iker
14th March 2018, 20:23
1. ::fr
2. ::pt
3. ::it
4. ::de
5. ::es (mostly due to recent revamp)
6. ::uk

revallsay
14th March 2018, 21:00
Big 6 sucks this year, but I will give it a go:

::1 ::it - the only songs I like from Big 6
::2 ::uk
::3 ::fr
::4 ::de
::5 ::es
::6 ::pt

Chorizo
14th March 2018, 23:09
::12 ::it
::10 ::fr
::8 ::pt
::6 ::es
::4 ::de
::2 ::uk

henhu
14th March 2018, 23:33
::12 ::it (5th)
::8 ::de (15th)
::6 ::pt (24th)
::4 ::fr (30th)
::0 ::uk (41st)
::0 ::es (43rd)

JonnyWest
15th March 2018, 01:54
::12::pt
::12::it
::10::fr
::8::es
::7::uk
::5::de

ag89
15th March 2018, 16:30
1. ::it
2. ::pt
3. ::de
4. ::fr
5. ::es
6. ::uk

LesterMalvo
15th March 2018, 17:19
::12 ::it
::1 ::fr
::0 ::uk
::0 ::es
::0 ::de
::0 ::pt

Fierro
15th March 2018, 18:05
::12 ::fr
::10 ::it
::8 ::es

::7 ::pt
::6 ::uk
::5 ::de

Soul
15th March 2018, 18:15
::12 ::pt
::10 ::it
::8 ::fr
::7 ::de
::6 ::es
::5 ::uk

Eulaliya
15th March 2018, 18:25
::12 ::it
::10 ::fr
::8 ::de
::7 ::pt
::6 ::es
::5 ::uk

cegs5
15th March 2018, 18:36
::12 ::fr
::12 ::it
::7 ::uk

::3 ::pt
::2 ::es
::2 ::de

Ezio
15th March 2018, 22:05
Very tough call to make

::12 ::pt
::12 ::fr
::10 ::it
::6 ::es
::5 ::de
::0 ::uk

Mio
16th March 2018, 06:45
12 Italy
10 France
8 Portugal

7 Spain
6 Germany
5 United Kingdom

GRE
16th March 2018, 08:23
12 Italy
10 Spain
8 France
7 Germany
6 Portugal
5 UK

Jukica
16th March 2018, 20:22
12 ::fr
10 ::pt
08 ::de
07 ::it
06 ::es
05 ::uk

ES2011
16th March 2018, 21:12
Deserve to be in the final
::12 ::pt
::10 ::de
::8 ::fr
::7 ::it

Borderline qualifier
::6 ::es

Non-Qualifier normally
::5 ::uk

Ichbinjari
18th March 2018, 14:44
1. Germany
2. France
3. Spain
4. United Kingdom
5. Italy
6. Portugal

popavapeur
18th March 2018, 14:57
::12 ::pt
::10 ::fr
::8 ::es
::7 ::uk
::6 ::de
::5 ::it

Muovivalas
18th March 2018, 15:15
::12 ::fr - my overall 2nd, lovely piece of music with touching lyrics
::10 ::it - quite catchy, I like the lyrics
::8 ::es - so cheesy you could use it as fondue, but I like it
::7 ::uk - always forget how this goes
::6 ::de - would prefer not to listen to this to the end
::5 ::pt - toilet break

joancamo
18th March 2018, 18:46
::12 ::fr
::10 ::pt
::8 ::it
::7 ::es
::6 ::de
::5 ::uk

MyHeartIsYours
20th March 2018, 03:42
::12 ::es
::8 ::de
::7 ::fr
::6 ::pt
::5 ::it
::5 ::uk

Gera11
20th March 2018, 03:49
::12::de
::10::fr
::10::pt
::8::es
::6::uk
::0::it

SwedishFailurez
20th March 2018, 14:43
So far...

::8::it
::7::pt
::7::fr
::5::de
::4::es
::2::uk

dannytr24
20th March 2018, 15:04
1. France
2. Germany
3. Spain
4. Portugal
5. Italy
6. United Kingdom

LalehForWD
21st March 2018, 13:40
12- Portugal
10- Germany
8- Spain
7- France
6- UK
5- Italy
In my opinion this is the strongest year for automatic qualifiers since 2012 & 2011. They all chose in Public national selections & the quality is much higher than it has been lately. Even the British song, which may be bland, is going to be well performed by an experienced Eurovision participant.

Odd, I think they all are pretty similar in an underwhelming way. Underproduced with a kind of brave naked expression, I think they will struggle hard to make an impression when it comes live in front of millions. Although she wasn't my favourite in You decide, I think SuRie will come on top of these. I usually struggle hard with ranking, but:

UK
France
Italy
Germany
Spain
Portugal

scratchthat2009
23rd March 2018, 01:39
1. ::es
2. ::it
3. ::fr
4. ::uk
5. ::pt
6. ::de

VikingTiger
23rd March 2018, 08:57
I actually cant remember any year where the big 5 and the host-country were all so far down my list. Only Italy and France (barely) is in my upper half of the scoreboard. Germany is somewhere down in my lower half - while UK, Spain and Portugal are to be found in my bottom 10.

Italy
France
Germany
UK
Spain
Portugal

JSSArcos
27th March 2018, 13:32
5 of these are in my top 15 xheat

::12::es
::12::it
::12::pt
::10::de
::10::fr
::3::uk

Tzeo
27th March 2018, 22:10
1.::fr
2.::uk
3.::it
4.::es
5.::de
6.::pt

Nando
4th April 2018, 19:43
::12 ::pt
::10 ::uk
::8 ::it
::7 ::fr
::6 ::es
::5 ::de

Simon87
5th April 2018, 21:07
Dont like any of them :lol:

Mrvn
5th April 2018, 21:15
::10::pt
::8::fr
::7::de
::5::es
::4::uk
::2::it

VascoRom99
6th April 2018, 19:32
I did some calculations because I wanted to see how this was going on a global scale.
These are the results:
1. France (373p) (most 10 & 8 points given)
2. Italy (368p) (most 12 & 8 points given)
3. Portugal (344p)
4. Germany (296p)
5. Spain (286p) (most 7 & 6 points given)
6. United Kingdom (253p) (most 5 points given)

Kevan1994
6th April 2018, 20:53
::12 ::fr
::10 ::it
::8 ::pt
::7 ::de
::6 ::es
::5 ::uk

aef
7th April 2018, 20:35
::12 ::pt
::10 ::it
::8 ::es
::7 ::fr
::7 ::de
::5 ::uk

toinou03
9th April 2018, 15:40
::12::pt
::10::fr
::8::it
::7::de
::6::es
::5::uk

Nicfedy
11th April 2018, 22:27
1 France
2 UK
3 Germany
4 Portugal
5 Italy
6 Spain

Sammy
11th April 2018, 23:05
1) ::de
2) ::fr
3) ::it



4) ::uk
5) ::es




6) ::pt

Franzilein
11th April 2018, 23:16
::12::it
::10::fr
::8::de
::7::pt
::6::uk
::5::es

esc87fan
12th April 2018, 01:36
::12::fr
::10::uk
::8::pt
::7::de
::6::it
::5::es

mauve
12th April 2018, 09:10
12 France
10 Germany
8 Italy
7 Spain
6 Portugal
5 UK